In one of the scariest moments in modern history, we're doing our best at ScheerPost to pierce the fog of lies that conceal it but we need some help to pay our writers and staff. Please consider a tax-deductible donation.
By Sharon Zhang / Truthout
Newly unsealed memos by the State Department on the Trump administration’s push to deport pro-Palestine student advocates have confirmed that officials knew the cases against the students were shaky and likely to run up against their First Amendment rights.
The documents were unsealed by a federal judge on Thursday. The case, brought by academic groups, has been full of bombshell revelations on the role of top officials like Secretary of State Marco Rubio in the campaign dubbed as “unconstitutional” by the judge last week.
The documents concerned five students who have been targeted by the Trump administration: Mahmoud Khalil, Rümeysa Öztürk, Mohsen Mahdawi, Yunseo Chung, and Badar Khan Suri. The memos were released in response to a request by news outlets to unseal them for the public interest.
In every case, the memos showed that the administration was seeking to remove students over some form of advocacy for Palestinian rights amid Israel’s genocide in Gaza.
On Chung and Khalil, the State Department claimed that the two Columbia University activists posed a “potentially serious adverse” foreign policy risk — an argument which legal experts have argued is shaky at best. However, it says that officials could not identify prior cases where people were deported under these grounds, and that “courts may scrutinize the basis for these determinations” as a result.
State officials further said that the Department of Homeland Security “has not identified any alternative grounds of removability that would be applicable to Chung and Khalil.”
Despite this, the Trump administration is still trying to deport Khalil. Last week, a federal panel reversed a federal court decision to free Khalil from immigration detention. And on Thursday, DHS Assistant Secretary for Public Affairs Tricia McLaughlin said in an interview on NewsNation that the Trump administration is seeking to rearrest Khalil and deport him to Algeria.
This threat comes even after a federal district court judge in Boston, Reagan appointee William G. Young, slammed the administration’s campaign against the students as blatantly unconstitutional actions by the highest levels of government.
Speaking about Rubio, DHS Head Kristi Noem, and President Donald Trump, Young wrote in his decision: “Talking straight here, the big problem in this case is that the cabinet secretaries and, ostensibly, the president of the United States are not honoring the First Amendment.” Young condemned Trump as an “authoritarian.”
The case was brought by two academic groups, the American Association of University Professors and the Middle East Studies Association, which brought up the cases of the students to argue that the administration was infringing upon students’ and teachers’ rights to speech as a result of their crackdown on dissent.
Disturbingly, the memos also revealed that the students were, indeed, targeted for simply exercising their rights to speech.
The memo on Öztürk, for instance, confirmed that the administration had solely targeted her for her op-ed in the Tufts University student newspaper advocating for the university to take action to support Palestinian rights. A judge ruled last month that Öztürk must be allowed to resume her studies after her visa revocation by the Trump administration, which has prevented her from teaching or participating in research.
This article was originally published by Truthout and is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0). Please maintain all links and credits in accordance with our republishing guidelines.
Editor’s Note: At a moment when the once vaunted model of responsible journalism is overwhelmingly the play thing of self-serving billionaires and their corporate scribes, alternatives of integrity are desperately needed, and ScheerPost is one of them. Please support our independent journalism by contributing to our online donation platform, Network for Good, or send a check to our new PO Box. We can’t thank you enough, and promise to keep bringing you this kind of vital news.
You can also make a donation to our PayPal or subscribe to our Patreon.
Sharon Zhang
Sharon Zhang is a news writer at Truthout covering politics, climate and labor. Before coming to Truthout, Sharon had written stories for Pacific Standard, The New Republic, and more. She has a master’s degree in environmental studies. She can be found on Twitter: @zhang_sharon.
Please share this story and help us grow our network!
-
The Palestine Exception: Why Academic Freedom Stops Here
A tenured professor can spend decades building a career, win awards, earn lifetime recognition, and still be discarded the moment political speech crosses an invisible line. That is what happened to Dr. Sang-hae Kil after she supported Palestinian protest on campus. Her teaching record was untouched, her scholarship praised, and a faculty panel ruled unanimously…
-
Silencing Student Reporters Threatens Public’s Right to Know
Jim Rodenbush for Project Censored I faced a decision last October that would dramatically change my professional and personal life. I could enforce a directive from Indiana University administrators to censor the Indiana Daily Student, or stand by my students’ right to editorial independence. What the administrators wanted was clear. The content of the printed version…
-
A Court Ordered Trump’s Department of Education to Roll Back Its Anti-DEI Efforts. Why haven’t Universities Reversed Course?
Last month, the department conceded that it could not make universities’ race-conscious efforts illegal, but universities nationwide have yet to reinstate their diversity, equity, and inclusion efforts Meghnad Bose and Luke Lawson for Prism The Trump administration suffered a major setback last month in its efforts to end educational institutions’ diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives. In…
-
Private Eyes on Campus: The New Era of Student Monitoring and Suppression
Posted by Joshua Scheer A few weeks ago we had a chance to speak with Hannah Epstein. Sadly, as the American empire descends into its last gasps, we have fallen behind on another vital series of stories taking shape in this modern dystopian America — the assault on academic freedom. We have our podcast here.…
-
America Faces a New “Sputnik” Moment, and Our Future Depends on Our Colleges and Universities
By Austin Sarat for ScheerPost It is hardly news that America’s colleges and universities are in serious trouble. Declining public confidence, politically motivated attacks, and the withdrawal of government funding have all contributed to a deepening crisis in higher education. Last month, the New York Times offered new evidence of that crisis, reporting that “American…
-
Fired for Doing Journalism? Inside the Crackdown on Student Press at UT Dallas
For ScheerPost’s Academic Freedom Project, we are looking to speak with both professors and student journalists covering what’s happening on their campuses and the attacks on the freedoms we hold dear. We understand there is a distinction between academic freedom, freedom of the press, and the First Amendment — but all are vital to a…
-
University of Texas Regents Approve Limits on Teaching ‘Unnecessary Controversial Subjects’
Opponents warned the policy’s vagueness could push professors to self-censor and leave students less prepared for the workplace.
-
“Tyrants Hate Truth”: Austin Sarat on the New War Against Academic Freedom
Welcome to Academic Freedom on Life Support, hosted by Joshua Scheer. In this episode, we speak with Austin Sarat, the William Nelson Cromwell Professor of Jurisprudence and Political Science at Amherst College, and one of the first contributors to our project examining the nationwide crisis facing higher education. Sarat argues that “academic freedom in the…
-
When a Deportation Case Falls Apart, Free Speech Is on Trial
Posted by Joshua Scheer In an era of hypercharged politics and hardened rhetoric around immigration, it is easy for individual cases to blur into abstraction. But every so often, one cuts through the noise — not because of what it proves about national security, but because of what it reveals about the fragility of constitutional…
-
From Civil Rights to Political Retribution: Trump’s Escalating War on Harvard
Posted By Joshua Scheer What began as a civil rights probe has metastasized into a naked political shakedown, with the White House demanding up to $1 billion from Harvard while threatening criminal prosecution and cutting research lifelines. The Trump administration’s war on higher education has entered its next predictable phase: sue first, subpoena everything, and…
-
Does Careerism Threaten Academic Commitment and Academic Freedom?
By Austin Sarat and Leah Schmalzbauer A survey of employers released on Jan. 13 brought bad news for college students entering the workforce in 2026. Among its worrisome results, “Small businesses are 30 percent more likely than larger employers to say they are not hiring recent college graduates in 2026. About 1 in 5 small-business…
-
Academic Freedom: Trump’s University Blackmail Results
The Trump administration has reached deals with six universities following the withholding of hundreds of millions of dollars in federal funds and grants.
-
2025 Rekindled Commitments to Academic Freedom Nationwide
The prospect of not having what we have long taken for granted has rallied the troops, offered academics and judges an occasion to articulate academic freedom’s value in new ways, and prompted a clearer appreciation of its value in the face of a rising threat of tyranny.