Decrying Gaza Genocide: The New Religious Left In Congress Challenges Christian Zionism

November 18, 2026

H. Scott Prosterman Informed Comment

The political tsunami that brought new blood to the U.S. House and Senate also set in motion a fresh dialectic to challenge the nativist Christian Nationalist movement in the U.S. While U.S. Ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee has been a forceful “Christian Soldier” in promoting illegal Christian and Jewish settlements in the West Bank, Texas Senator-Elect James Talarico is one of the newly elected officials poised to re-direct that narrative. Convicted felon Donald Trump has benefitted from his alliance with white Christian nationalists, who perceive him as a modern-day King Cyrus, a powerful heathen sent by God on their behalf. Though Trump has shown to be the most unspiritual man to sit in the Oval Office, they bought his con because he also appeals to their sense of nativism, racism and exclusion.

African-American politicians such as the Rev. Ralph Warnock (D-GA) in the Democratic Party have long appealed to a sense of Christian justice, and the late President Jimmy Carter famously combined his Baptist faith with center-left positions.  Still, this fall’s crop of preacher-representatives on the Democratic side of the aisle are remarkable.

Now come seminarians such as Talarico, Kansas Senator-Elect Adam Hamilton, and Texas Congressman-Elect Frederick Douglass Haynes III with historic upset wins. Their political strength comes in part from their objections to the MAGA Christian Nationalist agenda, and its misapplication to justify Israeli colonialism. The movement that empowered Trump, and fueled the January 6 riots is now being challenged by Christians who “walk the walk,” rather than those who twist the teachings of Jesus into instruments of hate.

The strength of Talarico, Hamilton and Haynes comes from their calling out how Evangelical Christianity has been misinterpreted to promote Trump’s very un-Christian agenda. Whereas Trump’s army of Christian soldiers violently stormed the Capitol to disrupt the electoral process, claiming divine empowerment; Pastor Haynes began his campaign by stating that Jesus opposed genocide in Gaza and anywhere in the world. Trump’s Christian soldiers are as devoted to the sanctity of firearms as they are to Jesus. The new wave of “walk the walk” Christian Democrats are positioned to challenge that position.

Their election brings a welcome “Christian counterpoint to the evangelical support for Israel that has long dominated the religious debate over the U.S.-Israel relationship.” They are deploying the momentum of the Blue Tsunami to counter that reflexive support for the Zionist enterprise and to reclaim modern Christianity for the actual teachings of the New Testament. The warped invocation of Jesus in Trump’s project has been a destructive force in American society, religion and politics. Anyone not invested in MAGA welcomes the new liberation theologians in the House and Senate.

Though all three of the figures mentioned above take exception to various Israeli military actions, there are subtle but notable differences in their approaches. Let’s examine their theological and political backgrounds, which led to this historical moment. Talarico has been a vocal critic of Christian Nationalism, and called it “a cancer on our religion.” Though he studied at Austin Presbyterian Theological Seminary, he was never ordained. Talarico been a forceful advocate of economic justice, separation of church and state, and public education free of religious influence. He also opposes book bans, and supports affordable childcare and paid family leave. He opposes U.S. sales of offensive weapons to Israel, but supports Israel’s right to defend itself from Iran and other enemies. Talarico advocates disarming Hamas and a two-state solution that recognizes Israeli and Palestinian sovereignty. But he opposes the unlawful Israeli squatter-settlements, and their ongoing expansion.

Haynes briefly succeeded Rev. Jesse Jackson as CEO and Director of the PUSH Rainbow Coalition in 2024 but resigned three months later to pursue his personal political agenda. His campaign platform included healthcare for all, abolishing ICE, opposition to genocide; and faith as a beacon for moral direction rather than a political tool for divisiveness. Haynes is the Lead Pastor at the Friendship-West Baptist Church in Dallas, a 13,000-member megachurch, which he founded in 1983 with 100 members.

His leadership style follows the Black Liberation Theology model of his dissertation subject, Rev. Jeremiah A. Wright, Jr. Their theology is derived from Rev. Martin Luther King’s merging of Christian theology with the core ethos of the Civil Rights Movement. That was the basis of King’s iconic “A Time to Break the Silence” speech at Riverside Church in New York City on April 4, 1967.  Rev. Wright’s model and motto is, “Unapologetically black, unashamedly Christian.” Some historians find it ironic how so many Black Americans express such deep devotion to the model of Christianity derived from the King James Bible, which was used as a tool of oppression against them. It’s admirable how they have reclaimed and repurposed it; while excising the divisive misuse and abuse of nineteenth- and twentieth-century white Christians. A parallel irony is that by reclaiming and reframing the Christian narrative, those men are positioned to counter the gross misuse of Christianity as a divisive weapon by Trump and his charlatan “spiritual advisers.” Haynes won Texas’s 30th Congressional District seat, which Jasmine Crockett gave up to run against Talarico in the Democratic Senate primary.   .

Haynes alarmed many supporters of Israel the day after October 7, when he delivered a sermon calling out Israeli apartheid, which distinguished him from Crockett’s unwavering support for Israel. Paraphrasing President Jimmy Carter, Hayes said, “Israel is engaging in apartheid with Palestinians. The Palestinians… don’t have the weaponry of Israel, the Palestinians don’t have the financial backing from the United States that Israel has. And so they throw their rocks and shoot their arrows, and Israel is able to bomb them and kill them. Watch in the news the disparity between Palestinians being killed and Israelis being killed. It is totally unfair. But this country is going to stand on the side of apartheid because that’s its track record.” One of his more profound comments was, “The racism we see in local zoning policies here at home and white supremacy in funding of a genocide in Palestine are cut from the same cloth.”


James Talarico, h/t his Senate campaign page. Public Domain.

Hamilton is the senior pastor of the United Methodist Church of the Resurrection in Leawood, KS. He supports a two-state solution for Israel-Palestine, and has called for halting offensive weapons sales to Israel, but supports defensive systems such as Iron Dome. Unlike Haynes and Talarico, Hamilton has avoided characterizing Israel’s actions in Gaza as “genocide.” But he said, “The atrocities of October 7 cannot be justified, but they must be understood in the light of the experience of Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank over the last 75 years. . . . seeing them (Palestinians) pass through checkpoints that treated them as prisoners in their own land . . .  opened my eyes to another side of this story . . . hearing a doctor . . . describe walking into his bombed home in Gaza, finding the dismembered bodies of his daughters after an IDF attack that targeted the wrong house, and other stories that led me to see the Palestinian side I’d never understood.” Hamilton continued, “There are grave injustices on both sides. Injustice breeds injustice.”

Another newly elected House member is Democrat LaKesha Womack, who is an ordained deacon at the African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church in North Carolina’s 14th District. She summarized the Blue Christian agenda by saying, “With the white Christian nationalists almost taking over the narrative of what it means to be a Christian, I think there are a lot of people of faith in this country who wanted to reclaim that narrative.”  And so they have.

Juan Cole’s Informed Comment delivers independent, expert analysis of war, the Middle East, climate change, and U.S. foreign policy. Help sustain this work

You can also make a donation to our PayPal or subscribe to our Patreon.

Please share this story and help us grow our network!

Subscribe
Notify of

0 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest