Nate Bear Do Not Panic
Last week Microsoft services went down, affecting businesses, governments, hospitals and other social services globally.
While it was pretty much resolved within 24 hours, it demonstrated how so many of our critical systems hang by a thin digital thread.
The outage, Microsoft says, wasn’t caused by hackers. But it’s only a matter of time before a major IT failure does go down this way.
In the wake of the outage, a cyber security engineer based in the UK wrote a long thread on twitter detailing why hackers will inevitably and eventually succeed in bringing down society-critical software. Within 30 minutes, this person had deleted their thread, after the replies accused them of fearmongering, of causing panic, of not giving enough specifics to be credible. All the usual complaints you hear whenever someone speaks honestly about the threats and dangers to organised society. Especially those that feel existential, and those we cannot control as individuals.
I can’t recall the details exactly, but I remember the gist. I remember the person began by saying “people have no idea what’s coming” and then explained that pre-AI a human hacker would fail 99.9% of the time, but AI gives a hacker the ability to run essentially unlimited amounts of code around the clock. An AI agent can probe weaknesses an infinite number of times, learn from failures, refine attempts and keep retrying constantly, and autonomously. A hacker starts a script running, then sits back and waits.

A few days after my post, Tech Crunch published an article about open source AI-powered penetration testing platforms that perform exactly as this person was describing.
The replies to the original post were angry and defensive. Because whether climate, pandemics or AI, people don’t want to hear about living within fragile systems. They don’t want to know about threats they can’t control it. They’d rather just let whatever is going to happen, happen, and deal with the consequences, or not, when they have to. Some dismiss it all as fearmongering which serves only the nefarious purposes of the elite.
On some level I get it.
If you’ve been reading me for a while, you’ll know that I’m not ideologically wedded to any of this shit we call civilisation. Specifically, an imperial-capitalist civilisation, especially as a complicit inhabitant of the imperial core. Any decent future for humanity relies on the downfall of these ideologies and the institutions, people and machines built to serve them.
But I am materially wedded to this system, whether I like it or not. As are most of us. The reality is that almost all of the systems we rely on for the functioning of our daily lives are undergirded by digital infrastructure. The pen is dead. Paper filing has been consigned to the past. Money can still be claimed nominally in coins and notes, but most transactions are digital. The world has been digitised. Which means that even the brief loss of just a small part of that digital infrastructure causes chaos. And this chaos, as chaos always does, hits the ordinary person, especially the most in need and disadvantaged, the hardest.
For example the Microsoft outage hit the NHS in the UK badly. C-sections were cancelled, ambulance services were disrupted, and operations had to be re-scheduled. Of course Microsoft is just one of the software and cloud computing providers which underpin the functioning of many businesses and governments in the west. Amazon, Google, Oracle, SAP, IBM and others are also integral to the running of our digitised world. But the shocking thing is there aren’t that many society-critical software providers. A bit of research tells me our societies and economies are almost totally reliant on around fifteen to twenty of these companies. If a few of them were to go down at the same time, the shit would hit the fan in ways we’ve never experienced. With the exchange of money for goods and services now almost fully digitised, everything would grind to a halt very quickly.
Can we do much about it? I’ve taken some steps to disentangle my existence from this digital infrastructure, but there is only so much I or most people can do, especially with limited resources. The reality is, as a relatively impoverished inhabitant of this world, I would quickly feel the effects if these systems failed. That said, I don’t think it’s a bad idea to buy a couple of extra jars of chickpeas with your weekly shop, have a stack of lighters in a drawer, and have some cash money under the bed. Being able to cope if everything goes down for a few days rather than scrambling unprepared on day one is definitely better than nothing. As well as some individual prep, building community in the relatively good times, and having a local network of people who can support each other and swap stuff, is probably the best insurance policy. But we should be under no illusions that exchange within a community would last forever under these conditions, or even very long at all.
But again, definitely better than nothing.
The other way we can prepare is mentally. This means accepting the fragility of modern systems, and understanding we exist atop a house of cards, and not letting it stress you out. It means not shooting the messengers, and instead listening to them. More than that, it means listening to them, letting the information in, and allowing it to shape you politically. A recent experience talking to a large group of middle class professionals, however, suggested to me that many have a very hard time with this idea. Many cannot bring themselves to see the world in 2026 as anything other than a world of progress, because they cannot bring themselves to doubt a system they so rely on. They have the smart watches and rings for the optimised bourgeois life, and can’t imagine living in any other way. To be honest, it’s not just the professional middle classes. Large numbers of people in general believe in the AI-powered cornucopia of forever comfort amid forever progress. And most know they couldn’t last five minutes without the conveniences granted by an industrialised and digitised existence, and therefore don’t want to think about.
I’m not making a claim for my resilience over people like this. I suspect I couldn’t last much longer than five minutes either. But I do feel obligated somehow to at least think about it. I do feel a responsibility to educate myself, and to build in some resilience, however minor. I suspect many of you reading this feel the same. And in my experience, a big reason many refuse to look honestly at the world is because they are reluctant to acknowledge their privilege. They are comfortable within a liberal centrist ideological framework that accepts the broad outlines of the world as it is. The status quo works for many, and they don’t want to be challenged by uncomfortable information that might threaten the way they understand the world and operate in it.
But if salvation lies anywhere, it’s in challenging these unsustainable systems that, paradoxically, sustain us.
A halfway decent future rests on challenging the billionaires who own the handful of digital systems that undergird our world. Systems we had no say in creating, and have no say in how they work. Systems that have created within many of us a state of learned helplessness. Systems we rely ever-more deeply on, to the delight of the billionaires.
Any hope for a decent future rests on enough of us challenging the AI kingpins, the data centre moguls, and the war machine mafia.
It rests on us letting the difficult information in so enough of us can correctly identify who the enemy really is.
I suppose my conclusion is one of the oldest in the (handwritten) book: no war but class war.
