ICC Says No Probe Of Alleged U.S. War Crimes in Afghanistan. It’s Wrong. It Disrespects Victims

November 19, 2026

Kathy Gannon Substack

Last week the International Criminal Court (ICC) decided not to prosecute alleged war crimes committed by U.S. forces in Afghanistan. The decision was no surprise. It reveals the international community’s disregard and disrespect for Afghans and Afghanistan.

The 2001 U.S.-led invasion ended in failure for Afghans with the return of the Taliban, but for the U.S., it got Osama bin Laden and degraded al Qaida. It was mission accomplished, even if they failed Afghans miserably. They left in a frightened and chaotic hurry, refusing today to return to help Afghans, where they live, claiming some moral high ground, they do not deserve to be standing on.

Even worse the United States today rounds up Afghans they helped flee the returning Taliban, shipping some to third countries, like Ghana. Others are awaiting the outcome of legal battles against the U.S. government’s attempts to deport them back to Afghanistan or to Pakistan, leaving it to the Pakistanis to send them to the home they fled in 2021.

Some NATO countries, who participated in the U.S.-led invasion, are no better. Germany is sending Afghan asylum seekers back to Afghanistan, with the help of the Taliban government, handing them the Afghan consulates in Germany to process deported Afghans.

And now the ICC is turning its back on Afghans, who suffered atrocities reportedly committed by U.S. and NATO soldiers as well as their Afghan government allies during their failed 20-year war.

It is wrong that the lives of those Afghans hurt by the U.S. and NATO are of less value than the victims of war crimes allegedly committed by the Taliban or the Islamic State in Khorasan province.

In 2021 the ICC decided to “deprioritize” alleged U.S. war crimes, as well as those committed by its Afghan government allies and instead focused only on alleged war crimes by the Taliban and the Islamic State in Khorasan Province.

Last week the ICC made it official. It went from deprioritizing to officially closing the books on cases alleging war crimes by the U.S. forces and NATO in Afghanistan. Prosecutors are appealing. The ICC says it will continue to investigate claims of war crimes committed by the Taliban, but not the Islamic State because that would just be too dangerous

Skeptics fear the ICC decision is a feeble attempt to appease a disgruntled Trump regime, who wants the court disbanded over war crime cases filed against Israeli leaders accused of atrocities in Gaza, where more than 73,000 Palestinians, including more than 22,000 children, have been slaughtered by Israel in brutal attacks on civilian infrastructure, including hospitals, churches, mosques and schools. There are outstanding warrants for Israeli Prime Minister (at least for now) Benjamin Netanyahu and Yoav Gallant, former Israeli defense minister.

The value and integrity of international laws has eroded dramatically in the last three years as the world watched in silence while Israel committed genocide, as declared by experts in the field, against Palestinians. Yet Afghanistan shows how selectively those laws have always been applied.

To sweep war crimes attributed to U.S. troops in Afghanistan under the rug is to ignore the significant number of documented cases charging torture, extrajudicial killing and illegal detainment by U.S. forces, crimes that will now no longer be investigated, nor will their Afghan victims receive justice.

Just last month Human Rights Watch laid out in detail crimes committed against Afghans, including by US. forces and questioned why their victims were not given justice, nor the perpetrators held accountable.

“Twenty-five years on, Afghans tortured in US custody and families of those wrongfully killed still have no clear path for filing a claim or receiving redress from the US government,” said Patricia Gossman, senior associate Asia director at Human Rights Watch. “Successive US administrations have swept grave abuses under the rug, leaving those most affected with neither compensation nor justice.”

There are numerous cases of atrocities committed by U.S., NATO and allied Afghan government forces. The U.N. Assistance Mission in Afghanistan kept yearly counts of civilian casualties by both the U.S.-led coalition, its government allies as well as their Taliban enemies. The numbers were always high , even as investigations were rare.

For example in 2019 the U.S. led coalition and its Afghan allies were blamed for 2,933 Afghan civilian casualties. Those were the documented ones. Many more were undocumented and often reported as suspected terrorists or Taliban fighters. Yet rarely, if ever, was the coalition or its Afghan allies required to provide proof.

Afghans in villages across the south and east of the country, where the Taliban were the strongest, routinely complained of being arbitrarily arrested by U.S. coalition forces and held for weeks, months and sometimes years. They were never charged, and never compensated for their illegal detainment.

Many complained of torture at the hands of both foreign and Afghan forces. Those complaints were rarely, if ever, investigated.

Last month’s Human Rights Watch report offered an Afghan farmer’s account of his ordeal __ an example of what many suffered.

“A farmer told Human Rights Watch that US forces detained him in Ghazni in 2019 while he was recovering from an eye operation. He said that he permanently lost his eyesight after US soldiers beat him during questioning and did not provide him with medical care. “Whenever one didn’t like my answers, the other American would hit me with his rifle butt,” he said. “They told me I was lying and beat me with fists, kicks, and rifle butts.” He was never charged but only released in August 2021.”

There has also been significant reporting on crimes committed by U.K. and Australian forces. For example, an Afghan detainee was executed by international forces because there was room on an awaiting helicopter for just six Afghan detainees. He was the seventh..

The U.K atrocities have been documented and in return the U.K government offered a feeble inquiry, but restricted the scope to 2010-2013. Why? What were they afraid of?

In 2019 Human Rights Watch published a 54 -page report documenting 14 cases from late 2017 to mid-2019 in which CIA-backed Afghan strike forces committed serious abuses, some amounting to war crimes.

“The United States Central Intelligence Agency (CIA)-backed Afghan forces have committed summary executions and other grave abuses without accountability, Human Rights Watch said in a report released today. These strike forces have unlawfully killed civilians during night raids, forcibly disappeared detainees, and attacked healthcare facilities for allegedly treating insurgent fighters. Civilian casualties from these raids and air operations have dramatically increased in the last two years,” Human Rights Watch said in 2019.

In 2001 Afghans welcomed the U.S.-led coalition and its Afghan allies, but by 2021, Afghans, most of whom did not want the Taliban to return, refused to fight and die to preserve the country the U.S.-led coalition and its Afghan allies had created over 20 years.

Soldiers, who hadn’t been paid in months, abandoned their posts and corrupt U.S. backed Afghan allies fled on the heels of the departing U.S.-led coalition troops, after losing their 20-year war to the Taliban.

Many of the tens of thousands of Afghans who fled with the aid of the international community have also been abandoned and for them their lives are a nightmare, but unsurprisingly the U.S and NATO has shown little regard for their plight.

Kathy Gannon is a former AP News Director for Afghanistan and Pakistan. Four decades reporting the fault lines of Afghanistan, Pakistan, Iran and the wider region. On-the-ground reporting and analysis from some of the world’s most misunderstood places.

Please share this story and help us grow our network!

This photo from the just-concluded summit in Shenzhen, China, accompanies our coverage because the International Criminal Court came up in talks among Presidents Vladimir Putin, Xi Jinping and Donald Trump.

Presidents Vladimir Putin, Xi Jinping and Donald Trump meet in Shenzhen, China, where they wrapped up an unprecedented three-way summit with a four-point agreement that Chinese media hailed as a landmark “peace declaration.” The agreement calls for reducing nuclear risks, expanding oil refining, pursuing United Nations reforms and limiting the jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court.

Trump singled out the court as an area where the three governments could work together.

President Donald Trump: “In another area of potential cooperation between us, I’ll be suggesting ways to protect our nation’s sovereignty from rogue globalist organizations such as the International Criminal Court, which has gotten out of control, which I believe we all agree has really strayed far from beyond its jurisdiction.”

The ICC has issued an arrest warrant for Putin over alleged war crimes in Ukraine, including the unlawful transfer of children from Russian-occupied areas. The United States, China and Russia are all outside the Rome Statute, the treaty that established the court.

Trump praised Xi and called Putin “my friend,” drawing a pointed response from Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk, who wrote on social media, “God, protect us from such friends.”

Subscribe
Notify of

2 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest