When Abdul El-Sayed Shattered The Islamophobia Trope, He Opened A Pathway For American Politics And A Future For Peace And Humanity  

November 16, 2026

Robin Andersen CounterPunch

The blue wave that wiped out the Republicans and brought Democrats back into the spotlight was called everything from a flood to a political earthquake, and other terms rendered with mirth and mocking on a The Daily Show montage, where TV anchors are seen reducing the night to a series of words like “rout” and “shellacking.” The term “Tsunamanani” was coined by Prem Thakker on Zeteo’s election-night coverage with Medhi Hasan, in a brief injection of comedic irony amidst real information and analysis. The night was all those things and more.

Arguably the most significant victory of the congressional sweep was Abdul El-Sayed’s win over Trump-backed extremist, Mike Rogers who ended up burning $70 million form AIPAC. Abdule will be the first Muslim ever to grace the floor of the US Senate. The joy of watching El Sayed’s smiling face as he shared the win was transcendent and hard to pull away from. But let’s contemplate the significance of his words and what this win means for redirecting American politics and building a future of peace and humanity. These words express that global future; “Michiganders, we want our taxes spent here, for schools here and healthcare here, and infrastructure here. We don’t want our money sent to do apartheid or genocide or war.”

When Abdul called out his name, “My name is Abdulrahman Mohamed El-Sayed, and I am so proud and honored to stand here as your senator elect,” the crowd roared. Throughout the campaign, right-wing enthusiasts used his whole name to brand him a “terrorist” and a “jihadist,” in efforts that spiraled after his primary win. Through the simple act of saying it, complete with Arabic intonation, the name that had been endlessly mocked for mouths by pundits and politicians, including Donald Trump, Adule demolished the rhetoric with, “Donald, look, I know you struggled with my name, so after JD swears me in in January, you could just go on and call me Senator.” The crowd roared again. He also called out JD Vance by directly addressing him with, “JD…Habibi.”

He told the crowd, “you might have noticed, I always say Inshallah or God willing, whenever the outcome of this race was mentioned. But today, tonight, we can turn that Inshallah into a…

Then 1:20 seconds into his speech the crowd shouted the word out together; “Alhamdulillah!,” then filled the hall with; Abdul. Abdul. Abdul. Abdul. Abdul. Abdul. Abdul. Abdul.

When we heard massive applause for his name and for one of the most common yet sacred words in Islam, translated from Arabic, we heard the shattering of the most powerful trope in politics today—Islamophobia—a weapon that has been used so effectively in promoting the worst impulses in American politics.

Left with no reasonable policy accomplishments and a wildly unpopular Donald Trump, Abdule was targeted by a relentlessly bigoted smear campaign. Anti-Muslim attacks didn’t come only from bots and social media influencers, they also drove policies that were on full display from the beginning, documented by the Center for the Study of Organized Hate that found the bigotry to be organized and extreme. The CSOH reported that “89 elected officials assembled a coordinated anti-Muslim campaign over thirteen months, publishing 1,111 social media posts, introducing eight bills, and forming a Sharia-Free America Caucus that grew to 65 members.” Dylan Williams at the Center for International Policy, complained to The Atlantic for tagging El-Sayed an “Islamist,” saying, “Come On. This is just open, unalloyed Islamophobia by your staff. Have you no journalistic integrity or common decency?”

Political advisors told El Sayed that “someone with a name and my story, a Muslim, was unelectable,” as if it were an unmovable grass-roots bias. Yet clearly Islamophobia is not organic; it has been carefully constructed and pushed with millions of dollars. As Medhi Hasan pointed out, the new wave of anti-Muslim rhetoric was a cynically designed false narrative; “the Islamophobia we’re seeing is not organic, this is not something people are all believing in.” It’s being used by Republicans to distract voters from failing economic policies, and “as a tool to manipulate public opinion.”Islamophobia spikes around elections.

Abdul El Sayed’s accomplishment was a major blow to a world constructed on the foundation of Arab and Muslim hate. The anti-Muslim trope that has engulfed the twenty-first century in endless conflicts was propped up by an ill-conceived and badly wrought thesis written by Samual Huntington, published in Foreign Policy Magazine in 1998, titled The Clashes of Civilizations. As Edward Said wrote in 2003 Huntington borrowed much of his mediocre model from The Roots of Muslim Rage published in 1990. Huntington envisioned a bifurcated world of endless conflict in a battle between the U.S. and the Muslim world. Clashes captured the minds of the American establishment and led George W. Bush to proclaim that the war on terror was a “crusade,” and a fight between us and them, civilization and barbarism, and good vs evil. That vision still holds sway over American militarism, most clearly illustrated with Doanld Trump’s disastrous war on Iran, complete with his threats to wipe out an entire “civilization.” It’s been a cornerstone of US Imperial wars, and its sentiments are indelibly displayed on Pete Hegeth’s body with tattoos of a Crusader’s Cross and the Arabic word for “infidel,” with other white supremacist symbols competing for his skin space.

Ending the use of toxic Islamophobia and its mindset, built as it is on a scaffolding of othering Muslims and Islam, was the challenge Abdul El-Sayed accepted when he entered the race for US Senate. He rejected the artificial divide between us and them and refused to be demonized. His skillful verbal panache is heart-felt and authentic, and his words are always his own. When Dr Sarah Jukaku, introduced her husband at his last campaign rally she said, with Abdule “what you see is what you get… no corporation, no billionaire, no special interest, no one tells him what to do or what to say.”

He offered voters an alternative, one notably humanistic and built on the promise of diversity, unity and a community of care. He put Gaza on the ballot as part of his vision.

Crossing the Divide

Abdul El Sayed is an American, a Midwesterner, a doctor and a husband who talks to his mother on a swing and pops up behind his grandparents on a videotape when affirming his midwestern values. Among his accomplishments working in public heath, was to provide glasses to 16,000 poor kids living in Detroit.

He is also a Muslim man with a long Middle Eastern name who speaks Arabic. He is, put simply, an American and a Muslim. He is the embodiment of a truth that lays bare the lies that have dehumanized Muslims for so long. When media present his religion as a threat to Americans, he doesn’t back down. He talks about Islam and his identity, using language that resides outside the boundaries of political explanation and the narrow mindset of those who would brand him “foreign.” He places his religion in the context of Judaism and Christianity with a videotape at a Rosh Hashanah dinner in conversation with his Jewish hostesses who recite a prayer, and then they enjoy home-cooked kugel together.

He invented new ways to talk about religion, in one campaign ad looking into the camera announcing that he prays, because all of us “need faith and hope that we can fix things.” The ad ends with, “I’m Abdul El-Sayed, man of faith, and that’s a good thing.”

Fighting attempts to demonize him, he offered moral clarity and he used his voice to open the aperture of American politics and offered a realignment of our political visions, of an America big enough for all of us. He allowed us to dream of the possibilities of a roomy inclusive America that roundly rejects the shrinking Trumpian world we’ve been occupying for too long, of violence, hate and exclusion, that place which is really just the dystopian outcome of Samual Huntington’s Clashes of Civilizations, and the Islamophobia it demands.

Gaza?

With the rejection of destruction, violence and hate, must also come the rejection of brutality and genocide. Just after the blue wave swept the US, heavy rains flooded 70,000 tents and inundated the shelters where displaced Palestinians live in the rubble of Gaza. As reported by Medical Aid for Palestinians MAP, Israel has blocked construction materials and other lifesaving essentials including medicines, and new tents and poles continue to be restricted. A rain-soaked embankment also collapsed onto the flimsy tents. Mandy Potankin, spokesperson for International Rescue CommitteeIRC, posted an AJ+ Reel of a Palestinian boy crying for help, pointing to the contaminated water and sewage-flooded tents where Gazans are forced to sit in water and sleep on rain-soaked filthy mattresses. After watching images of the flooding, artist and photographer Misan Harriman, posted a powerful video, speaking into the camera with tears in his eyes, pleading with world powers to stop this deliberate brutal suffering and carnage. His words enrage and set your heart on fire. He reawakens an inner voice that demands we don’t turn away but do something to stop this.

At the same time, the horrors and brutality against Gazans are cause for celebration and mocking in Israel, best illustrated by popular Israeli whether forecaster and TV personality Tzachi Peleg, who openly gloated while showing images of submerged tents saying, “In the Strip, they probably went out to fish in the morning and not to the beach. Such happiness, I haven’t experienced since the sixties.” Tzachi Peleg told Israeli’s that not a single tent would remain, adding that he had “no problem if people do not survive there either.”

Israelis sparked widespread outrage on social media after they gleefully shared Peleg’s mocking reports with one comment describing the scenes as “wonderful.”

Renowned psychologist, Dr. Gabor Maté understands the origins of this utter contempt for human life and dignity—this psychosis—now rampant in Israel. On a Double Down News Video he explains that many early Zionists did envision a society that was socialist, just and human, but they always excluded Palestinians from that vision. He argues that once you decide that somebody is worth less than you are, that somebody has fewer rights than you do, that you have the right to override somebody else’s needs, reality, history and cultural existence, you must be ever more brutal in suppressing them when they defend themselves. Consequently, you must “envenom yourself.”

As Arab-American writer Yahia Lababidi agreed, “Venom poisons most the people who carry it.” Maté concludes that with such extreme dehumanization it’s very accurate to describe Israel as a brutal society functioning like a psychopath.

As the Western world looks on, government elites fail to compel Israel to stop the killing, and legacy corporate media carry on dehumanizing Palestinians with pro-Israel fames that justify Israel’s genocide, as the psychotic state continues to block life-saving aid and materials, compounding the horrors of destroying the civilian infrastructure of Gaza. Matéadded the words of Arundhati Roy who referred to this phenomenon as “the infrastructure of impunity, concluding that Israel right now is “a psychopath functioning in an infrastructure of impunity.”

By contrast Palestinian men continue to be dehumanized and demonized, as one Substack writer posted in defense of Palestinian men, “They keep watch over our villages at night and dig our children out of the rubble with their bare hands. Yet, the world insists they are undeserving of life.”

Moving Forward

Abdul El-Sayed used his voice to open the aperture of American politics and offered a realignment of our political visions, and offered a big inclusive America. He allowed us to dream of possibilities and diversity in America that roundly rejects the shrinking Trumpian world we’ve occupied for too long, of brutality and exclusion. Abdul El Sayed has delivered a major blow to a world constructed on the foundation of Arab and Muslim hate, by presenting an alternative. In doing so he became the embodiment of a politics of joy, care and concern. He offered justice and equality and what it would mean to live in an America all but lost in our imaginations by the realities of this waring world.

With his call to end the genocide of Palestinians, Abdul joined the choros of public voices across the globe, from celebrities to filmmakers to football players, and humanitarians like Ms. Rachel and Francesca Albanese, and all those who plead with the world to fold Gazans into humanity’s embrace and consider Palestinian lives equally as worthy as others, and end the horrors of Israel’s extermination campaign.

As the Nation Magazine wrote on November 10th, Democrats have an “unequivocal mandate” to break with Israel now, adding that it would be “insane” for the party not to fundamentally change the US-Israel relationship. Americans have raised their voices demanding to block all the bombs, and there is no other cause as compelling at this moment for realizing El-Sayed’s vision than stopping Israel’s genocide before it’s too late.

Ending the genocide would be a huge step in fulfilling the dream of a politics of care, justice, prosperity, and psychic well-being by freeing us all from having to live with genocide. Now the so-called “centrist” or “moderate” Democrats must decide whether to champion a new anti-Islamophobic politics or keep taking money from hate mongers and mass murders and suffer the consequences of the political blowback that wiped out the Republicans.

Robin Andersen is the author of The Complicit Lens: US Media Coverage of Israel’s Genocide in Gaza, published by OR Books, and the Institute for Palestine Studies. 

Independent media needs voices that challenge power—and CounterPunch delivers, with sharp reporting, uncompromising commentary and perspectives pushed to the margins of corporate news. Explore CounterPunch for free articles and podcasts, and donate to help keep its reader-supported journalism alive.

You can also make a donation to our PayPal or subscribe to our Patreon.

Please share this story and help us grow our network!

Subscribe
Notify of

0 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest