NYT Reporting On Iranian Dams Risks Justifying War Crimes: Normalizing Violence

November 21, 2026

Fatemeh Keshavarz Informed Comment

 Even before the beginning of the war, which Americans rejected decisively at the ballot box, there has been talk of Iranian dry climate as its Achilles’ heel. As early as 2021, the Atlantic Council published on Iran’s environmental woes .

   A new wave of terror is going through the minds of many Iranians regarding the 500 plus dams in their country since the publication of an article in New York Times on November 16: War May Answer Longtime Riddle of Iranian Dams Built for No Clear Reason.  Through a series of unverifiable speculations made by a few “experts,” embellished with the authors’ own conspiratorial guess work, the article suggests that these dams, built in Iran over the past few decades were likely created to cover and support underground missile construction sites. One “evidence” which can apply to any country is that: “Iran has a strong incentive to ensure that its missile complexes are not dependent on the broader national infrastructure for essential services.”

One “dam expert” visiting Iran and “perusing news about the war in his home country,” is said to come across a map plotting airstrikes that had targeted suspected military sites.”  He suggests that these sites “nearly matched that of his own map marking the locations of dams.”  Since lay visitors could not access materials as sensitive as a map of strikes on the Iranian military facilities, what he is referring to is the US and Israeli strikes on dams assumed to be sitting atop such facilities.  The authors of the article seem to be aware of the shaky nature of this claim which could normalize, even encourage, ecocide.  But they do next is even less convincing. “Iran’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the Ministry of Energy, which is partly responsible for dam construction,” they add “did not respond to requests for comment.” Neither did “Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps, which also plays a role in dam construction.” Did they expect Iranian authorities to verify attacks on their missile sites to the newspaper of record, in the country that threatens to wipe Iran off the face of the earth at least once a week? Or is it an attempt to professionalize the reporting?

What follows, suggests the latter. Looking for something that resonates with the public at large, and shows where Iran really belongs, they revive the dated rhetoric of the Axis of evil. “Very few countries” they explain “maintain as elaborate a system of underground military sites” as do Iran and North Korea. That the underground facilities may have been built in anticipation of unprovoked unilateral violence by the hand, that according to Secretary Rubio, carries the sword and does not worry about the law, is not raised.

They touch on another trigger point, reference to arrests, imprisonment, and torture. Victims include “conservation workers” who placed cameras to track rare animals and “may have accidentally happened upon sensitive military sites.” To introduce a note of ridicule about Iranian “Revolutionary Guards intelligence arm” a demeaning joke is thrown into the mix. Someone accused of using environmental activities as cover for intelligence gathering suggests “One of the accusations leveled against me was that I had trained lizards to spy on military installations.”

It is possible that the Guards saw people doing fieldwork near these dams, even wildlife conservationists, as a potential security threat, somebody else says. In that case, arrests and interrogations are believable too. It is also possible that building some of the dams have been influenced, “At least in part, by military considerations,” as another interviewed person suggests. But each of these are major issues that require independent investigation. Normalizing violence that could result in ecocide based on such murky arguments, will replicate the “reasoning” behind the genocide in Gaza where civilians are targeted because Hamas is said to take cover among them.

Spending the lion share of the article normalizing potential attacks on the suspicious dams in Iran, the authors confess that “A definitive explanation remains elusive.” Sadly, this most reliable finding of the article says too little and comes too late. As does a reference to the U.S. airstrike in Tarom, a Protected Area of Hormozgan in Iran, which killed the family of a local wildlife ranger in the process.

You can also make a donation to our PayPal or subscribe to our Patreon.

Please share this story and help us grow our network!

Subscribe
Notify of

0 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest