Who Drives Trump’s Foreign Policy? Ray McGovern and Craig Murray on the Wars in Iran and Ukraine

November 22, 2026

Joshua Scheer

After Ray McGovern publicly challenged Donald Rumsfeld over Iraq, CNN’s Anderson Cooper wanted to know whether he’d been afraid. As McGovern tells it, Cooper asked him the same question twice, first on the phone and then on air. Recalling the exchange at Dublin’s Whistleblower bookshop, the former CIA analyst made a point that runs through the entire evening. Why should questioning a defense secretary about a war seem like an act of courage in the first place?

In this CN Live! discussion from Consortium News, McGovern, the 2026 James Joyce Award laureate, joins former British ambassador Craig Murray to examine how governments justify wars abroad and handle dissent at home. McGovern points to former U.S. counterterrorism official Joe Kent’s resignation as a rare public break with the Trump administration over the war on Iran. He also questions whether Washington’s stated desire to end the war in Ukraine can be reconciled with what he describes as continuing U.S. intelligence support for Ukrainian strikes inside Russia. In Dublin, that discussion comes closer to home when he recalls protests against the use of Shannon Airport by the U.S. military.

Murray brings the question of dissent to Britain, discussing arrests of people who publicly supported Palestine Action and the legal challenges to the group’s ban. McGovern returns to it through the case of David McBride, the Australian military lawyer who went to prison after leaking documents that helped expose alleged war crimes in Afghanistan. The two cases raise a question that gives the evening its urgency. What can the public learn about a war when the people who disclose what happened, or organize against it, are the ones who have to answer in court?

Read the transcript below of Ray McGovern and Craig Murray’s Consortium News conversation on the wars in Iran and Ukraine, recorded at The Whistleblower bookshop in Dublin.

Robert Parry helped expose Iran-Contra and went on to found Consortium News in 1995 to give investigative reporting a home online. Visit Consortium News for independent reporting and analysis that challenge official accounts of war, foreign policy and U.S. power.

You can also make a donation to our PayPal or subscribe to our Patreon.

Please share this story and help us grow our network!

Live at The Whistleblower: Craig Murray and Ray McGovern

Originally published by Consortium News as part of CN Live! on November 21, 2026. Recorded at The Whistleblower bookshop in Dublin.

Editor’s note: This transcript was edited from the supplied automatic captions for readability. Timestamps, verbal fillers and obvious repetitions were removed, and speaker labels and section headings were added. Brackets mark unclear wording. Speaker identifications were inferred from context, and the captions were not checked against the recording.

Iran, Ukraine and U.S. foreign policy

Ray McGovern: One has to remember that Trump was following Israel in these fights. Iran is no threat to us, and it’s perceived to be a threat to Israel. It’s the Israelis who think that. And so we joined in at the behest of Netanyahu.

Now some good things happened at that point. Rubio and John Ratcliffe, the arch-Zionists, stayed in power, but Joe Kent, who was about number three in the intelligence order. Joe Kent, head of the National Counterterrorism [Center], quit. And he quit with a respectful but detailed explanation as to why he quit. And he said there was no immediate threat. The Israelis made us do it. What he said was the Israelis and the Israeli supporters in Washington got us into this. I’m sorry, Mr. President, but I have to leave. A resignation on principle that happens in Washington once every 200 years. Okay. So, what else did Joe tell us? Well, he told us about I’ll get back to a couple other things, but you know what has eventuated is with Russia and China being understandably concerned where this might lead with a very mercurial president. They have appealed to his ego and his narcissism and everything else.

And in a word, you have the Chinese Xi Jinping visiting Washington about three or four weeks ago. And what does he say in the communiqué? The Chinese say well strategic cooperation. We’re striving for strategic cooperation with one another with China and Russia and the US and Xi has decided to come to Miami for the G20 meeting in December and most of all Trump has decided to come to China where he is right or just left really for the big meeting of [unclear] meeting. Now, I ask you, that’s it.

That’s as much as they could agree to. Well, yes. What’s the whole deal here? They want to keep Trump busy. They want to keep him in the limelight. They want to keep him so he won’t do stupid stuff like joining Netanyahu and invading or attacking Iran again.

Let’s just say a few words about Ukraine. On August 15 of last year, there was the Anchorage summit. Now the Russians have made it very clear and no one has denied that they pretty much prepared this thing and they read their position at the summit and they confirmed that this is what the previous negotiators people like what Witkoff and Kushner, Witkoff in particular, had said they were going to do. It disabused the president of the United States that he could get a ceasefire, no ceasefire. He gave up on that one. Even though he said to a Fox News person

On the way to Anchorage, I’ll be very disappointed if I don’t get a ceasefire because he should have known there was not going to cease fire. What was the deal? The deal was that the Europeans and the Ukrainians would talk about how to resolve this thing and that in addition to that they would meet and they would they convene at the White House of course and they got instructions I thought from the president. He was very blatant about where his priorities were when he was interrupted by a phone call from Putin. He said, “Would you all the rest of you people would you wait? There’s coffee and donuts out there. I have to take a call for from my friend Putin.” But I thought they were given the riot act, but not. So now there was an early indication of this

And we Kremlinologists noticed these things, right? So what happened at the very end of the summit Putin gets up and gives a pretty nice picture. We had nice conversation, good speech and good and then at the end of it he says and we’re going to meet again and then he says next time in Moscow and Trump looked like a deer blinded by the headlights and what did he say? Anybody remember? Oh, that would be really something that we have to see. Oh, I opposition. I don’t know if I can. Now, why said there’s an early sign? I mean, here’s the president of the United States, right? He’s got Putin in the United States and Putin says next time in Moscow and he can’t even agree to say, okay, next time in Moscow. No, he’s got to contend with these troglodytes in his own entourage, these Zionists and these other people who favor continuing wars with Ukraine and everything else. So that was an early sign. Now, what followed from that of course was a whole couple of months where the Europeans decided that they would oppose this. They would give Zelensky some more billions of dollars. And for what it’s worth, Putin, like me, is left with the impression, well, who the hell’s in charge here, you know? I mean, u, the president told me, says Putin, that he would rein in the Europeans. We gave some concessions. The Russians said, we made some concessions. You know, we could deal with the territorial issue. We deal with all of it. And all of a sudden, the Europeans say no.

And not only that, but the US, the CIA provides the wherewithal to send drones and missiles deep inside Russia not to do any eternal harm, but to, you know, kill people and put out some of their oil facilities. Now, Trump says he wants peace in Russia in Ukraine. And the Russians say, “Well, that’s very nice. Why the hell do you let John Ratcliffe and the CIA give all this information from satellites so they can target our country?” Well, I

Don’t know what Trump says by that, but I do know what Joe Kent says. And Joe Kent was right in the middle of it. I also know what Doug Macgregor who worked for Trump at the or who worked at the very end of the previous regime what they both say is that the deep state slow-walks things. You know, sometimes they just disobey things and sometimes they just keep doing what the president tells them not to do. And so the president really is not his own man. But the Russians and the Chinese have to act as though he were try to kick him with kid gloves so he doesn’t go halfcocked and so he doesn’t join Israel in doing what happened before. I was just reminded to say something about Joe Kent. What was it?

It’ll come I’ll come back to it. But this is the dumb bit. Now when Putin addresses these questions, here’s the epitome of a Cool Hand Luke. Okay, you’re not going to be provoked by any of this stuff. These are pinpricks compared to the damage that the Russians are doing to bridges now and other facilities in Ukraine. It’s just a matter of time because the Russians are in the Dnipro River and they can also take other parts of the region east of the Dnipro. So when Putin talks in candid ways as he most usually talks and you know call me a person who tries to understand Putin that’s not a pejorative I think we should try to understand Putin. So when he talks he says look here’s the situation Europe is a formidable opponent they have a larger economy than we do. They have what twice as many people as we do. They seem to still hate us. And so we have this disadvantage. And so we’re well armed and can deal with this. But just remember that if we have to, we will resort to all means at our disposal. Okay? Now, why you say that? Well, sotto voce, that is nuclear weapons. But these crazy people in Europe, I mean, Merz or these other people are saying, you know, well, let’s take Kaliningrad, that kind of stuff.

Putin really has to be very careful in saying look we recognize that there’s a disequilibrium in power in terms of economy and other things and military you know we dominate but we don’t want to you know we don’t want to go into Poland or Baltic states despite what Joe Biden said [unclear] so I’ll just kind of point out more close to home here that with respect to the triple lock.

Shannon Airport and whistleblowing

I was here with the delegation Tarak Kauff and Ken Mayers were arrested on the airfield there in Shannon airport for coming and then trying to prevent US airplanes from with weapons and with armed soldiers from going to Iraq and Afghanistan. I mean this really happened. I know their names. They were with our delegation. Now Ken Mayers and Tarak Kauff did this protesting but also in our delegation was a person named Enya Andreas and Mike Haynes. Enoy was with the army. Mike Haynes was a cracker jackack marine trained in special forces. They both came through with their weapons for God’s sake. With their weapons full you know full suited through Shannon stopped in Shannon so you know this business about well we can’t really find out if there any weapons well they testified that they bought their weapon no when they had a [Unclear passage about the weapons aboard the plane.]

Well anyhow I want to make that point because the triple lock seems to be in some danger and I’ll just end there with saying that I’m delighted to be able to also introduce my friend Craig Murray and just a word about how I first knew of Craig when he resigned or when he pointed out to the foreign office that he didn’t think it was right for the CIA to be getting the Uzbeks to torture people so that they could make confessions and then count up new terrorists that They put in these camps to terrorize some more or to torture some more. And the foreign officers, I recall, said, “Well, are we doing that? Are we British doing that?” No, says, “Craig, it’s the Americans.” Oh, well, forget about it. It doesn’t really matter. And Craig didn’t think that was quite right. And so it was very clear that he was going to be cashiered and he couldn’t really exist in this atmosphere where his former foreign office colleagues could condone this kind of thing and you know say well it’s not our business it’s our it’s the Americans. I’ll just say that when we

Established the Sam Adams Award for Integrity, we had some pretty big people, but we had women, the first three, Coleen Rowley, Katharine Gun, one other woman, and then we were desperately we want to be balanced here. We want to have a man. Craig Murray. We invited him to token and he spoke eloquently about how he felt about torturing individuals and he so he is our fourth Sam Adams honore.

Our 25th was given this award yesterday in Australia. He is David McBride. If you want to read about that, read Consortium News has a couple of pieces on that. David McBride pointed out that the Australian soldiers, their special forces were doing all kinds of torture and other things. So they put him in jail for two years, right? The good news is not only that he won the award, we learned in the process that he’s cancer free. They had given up for loss, but they cut out the stuff his lung and he’s told now that he’s cancer free. So he’s the 25th. Craig was the fourth. Julian Assange Daniel Ellsberg, it’s a really good group that we have together. And so without further stuff from me, Craig, thanks for being with us. And I’m happy to have you as a friend as well as a colleague.

Free speech and political dissent

Craig Murray: If anyone’s still outside it’s a good moment to walk past if you want to come this side the I met the nice lady in the room downstairs when we were having a glass of wine and she said that she’d been following me online for years and it reminded me I was giving a talk in Brussels and the lady came up to me and said “Are you Craig Murray?” and I said yes and she said oh I thought you were only online [laughter] [laughter] which is quite extraordinary took me some time after that to convince myself I am real

If you go online, you can see a talk I gave last year to Pensioners for Independence in Glasgow. And that was a talk I went on for I think an hour and 10 minutes before they told me to shut up. And during that hour and 10 minutes, you can actually see on the video I drink six pints of Guinness without even noticing I was doing so. Quite impressive. I’m only going to speak to 15 minutes here and I have no Guinness. But I will nonetheless see what I can do. I’m still running well from last night because last night Ray was presented at the university with the James Joyce Award which I think does as much honor to the James Joyce Award as it does to Ray. It was actually very [applause] and afterwards we went for dinner and after dinner we went to the bar and then that bar closed and then we went to another bar and Joe Lauria here from Consortium News forced me to keep going around Dublin looking for more bars and it’s at the time after about I don’t know nine or ten pints a it seemed normal somehow but in fact when I think back about it. In some of those bars, young people seem to come out without putting all their clothes on. It was very strange. And we ended and I got home. It was daylight. And I haven’t been to bed since. So if I’m not as coherent as I normally am, I do hope that you will forgive me. Thank you. That’s very kind. May is going to forgive me. We’ll see whether you forgive me by the time I’ve by the time I finish.

We live in extraordinary times. I had dinner with Chay Bowes two nights ago where I bought him dinner which is against the law. It is against the law to provide him with the means of sustenance. And we took a photo. We took a photo of ourselves and sent it to Kaja Kallas [laughter] saying here I bought him dinner. Come and arrest me. It’s a f I sent the photo to a friend who said, “I didn’t realize you’re getting so old. You’re shrinking.” I said, “I’m not shrinking. A man’s a bloody giant. Have you met him? He [laughter] is enormous.”

Looking through what’s happening in the western world today, it’s very difficult. We’re living in a authoritarian times. I and my family have had to discuss whether it’s safe for us to continue living in Edinburgh. Yeah. I’ve never hurt anybody in my life. I’ve all I’ve done is say things. I was in Russia about three weeks ago, four weeks ago. Do you know in the UK last year 21 in over the last 12 12 months 21,000 people have been arrested for speech offenses. 21,000 people. That includes the 4,000 people who’ve been arrested for supporting Palestine Action. Of those other 21,000 there are there is a section who I think should be arrested they’re people who sent threatening messages to their spouse for example you know they’re people but that’s a tiny subset of that number the vast majority of those are people who just been arrested for saying hurty things online you know saying things that the state doesn’t like

And when I was in Russia I decided to do some rese research and I spoke not just to official Russian government sources. I spoke to Memorial and others and the equivalent figure in Russia for people who were arrested for any form of speech crime is about 2,000 not 21,000. Of those about 1,800 people were arrested for speaking against the war in Ukraine. Now personally I’m very sorry that 1,800 people in Russia have been arrested. I don’t think anybody should be arrested for that. I think that’s bad. The vast majority of those were fined rather than imprisoned. But even so, I still don’t think they should have been arrested. But the situation on free speech is much worse in the UK than it was in Russia. Twice as many people, more than twice as many people are arrested in the UK for supporting Palestine Action as arrested in Russia for speaking against the Ukraine war. And let’s just look at Ukraine.

In Ukraine, 11 political parties are banned. 11 political parties which have had MPs in the last decade. Not 11, you know, non-existent or paper political parties. The parties that are banned include the Socialist Party, the left party, and the Communist Party. They are all banned and illegal in Ukraine. And yet here we are being urged to accept conscription, being urged to accept a welfare state being slashed, public spending being slashed, real wages falling, standards of living falling in order to justify far greater spending on arms and weapons because apparently we’re in a fight for democracy [laughter] against Russia. It’s bollocks, isn’t it? It’s actually just a completely false narrative, but it’s a narrative with which we are imbued day by constant propaganda. And think of this, in Russia, the BBC have Steve Rosenberg,

BBC Moscow correspondent, who every day is able to go around Russia producing anti-Russian pieces. He’s able to interview Putin and put out stuff. Some of which is true, some of which is dubious, some of which is untrue. But why shouldn’t it? That is freedom of expression and the Russians permit it. Yeah. And here in Ireland, you have an Irishman, Chay Bowes, whose life is being destroyed, whose family are being complete, he’s got four young kids here in Dublin, whose family are being completely messed about because he says nice things about Russia, because he says disobliging things about Ukraine.

The notion that we live in a free speech democracy and that we live in a world of camps of good against evil and we are the goodies is nonsense. I actually don’t think there are any goodies. I’ve always felt that you would find that almost anybody who gets to the summit of political power in almost any country. Not there’s the odd exception but 90% of the time they got to the summit of political power because they’re an evil bastard because that’s how you get to the summit of political power. And that applies throughout the world. Yeah. So, but the notion that you know the world of Donald Trump, the world of Andy Burnham,

Public debt, private wealth and the arms industry

These are the good guys. It’s we are being sold this monstrous lie.

Thomas Piketty, a French economist, published some statistics at the time of the large demonstrations in France and he said that in France in 1970 he said public debt the national debt was 20% of GDP. It is now 120% of GDP. Almost exactly the same thing is true in the UK. It was a bit higher in the UK in 1970 because of continuing World War II debt. But the same rough thing has happened over most of Europe. Many of us remember when you had to have public debt of you had to have national debt of below 40% of GDP in order to join the European Union or join the Euro which neither Germany nor France would be able to do on today’s figures.

Piketty said that since 1970 national debt has risen in France from 20% to 120%. But if you look at wealth, private wealth, the accumulation of wealth owned in France between 1970 and now that has risen from 300% of GDP to 600% of GDP. There’s actually a far greater gap. There’s far more wealth compared to debt than there was and for the reason to explain that I’m not an economist. It’s subtraction rather than division which is the relevant measure. There’s far more wealth compared to debt than there was than there ever has been. France is now wealthier than it has ever been. But the problem is that all the debt is in the public sector and all the wealth is in the private sector and that wealth is incredibly concentrated. If you look at Oxfam’s figures on the UK, [unclear]. It’s almost certainly the same in Ireland. It’s the same all over the world. What we and we have this situation where debt is nationalized and wealth is not only private wealth is in the hands of a tiny sector of the population and it’s led to all kinds of

Economic distortions. It doesn’t happen naturally. This is not the natural order of things. This is due to a bunch of specific institutions, specific laws, governmental institutions and private institutions. All of which are aimed at and projected towards the concentration, the extreme concentration of wealth. The situation in which you and I work our butts off our entire lives and never have much to spare and other people have billions and billions. That’s not a natural phenomenon. They try to make you believe that is the natural order of things. It is not in any sense the natural order of things. It is a deliberate and careful state construct. So we live in this strange society where that gr that wealth gap is growing and growing.

And if you look at the terrible things that happening in society, if you look at the war in Ukraine, if you look at the genocide in Gaza and the way that’s being sustained by the weapons industry, the amount of money they sort of I mean, we’ve all cried real tears, I think, when we’ve seen some of the images from Gaza over the last few years. That night I think all of us have there’s probably nobody here who hasn’t at some stage cry there are people who have made billions out of that there are people involved in weapons manufacturing supplies and security who have made billions out of the genocide in Gaza these things don’t happen purely for reasons of atavistic hate or racism but those of course are factors they happen because of the economics of settler colonialism, the economics of war, the economics that want all of us to spend more of our money on things that kill people rather than things that create or enhance life or make the world a better place. That is where we are today and it’s a world which is becoming increasingly dangerous for those of us who oppose it.

But I want to put to you this. I see some hope. I think that the reason for this everinccreasing authoritarianism particularly in western states is that they are scared of us. I think once you reach a certain stage of wealth inequality, a certain stage where people realize that there is no hope their lives are going to get better. Nobody has any serious hope that their children are going to have better lives than they did or own more than they did or progress more than they did. Social mobility has died in the western world. Once you take away hope from people, once people merely become hopeless, then revolutionary sentiment starts to bubble up. I was in Madrid last week in a huge demonstration about half a million people walking through the streets because of the incredible cost of housing in which is part of this entire construct.

Popular. There are signs of popular resistance going up all over Europe. And the fact that thousands of people are willing to be arrested because of their support for Palestine Action is another sign of that popular resistance. And when popular resistance grows, then authoritarianism has to react by becoming more and more authoritarian. But eventually it will break. A better world is possible and it all depends on our own courage, our own individual good acts to keep fighting it. Thank you very much indeed.

Audience Q&A

[applause]

Unidentified speaker: Questions? I have a question.

Audience member: As a Kremlinologist, I was curious. From here from the western side it would appear like after the second world War, Reinhard Gehlen moved over to the American side. On the Japanese side, [unclear]. From the Eastern perspective of China and Russia, is there a feeling that America just switched sides at the end of the war? [Unclear.]

Ray McGovern: Well, I’m going to go back to one of my grandmother’s least favorite people, and that is Winston Churchill, who at the end of the war said, “Well, now let’s go after Russia.” it’s in the records folks he said look we’re all build up the Russians are creamed They have no real economy but let’s “Let’s do it.” And cooler minds prevailed. That’s that it wasn’t just the US it was the people who led us astray mostly

The English. Now you mentioned Reinhard Gehlen who headed up the Russian intelligence part of the Wehrmacht. He was welcomed to be a head of a subsection of the CIA really they set it up as a different kind of organization is now the BND and it’s become more and more powerful because he had all the information on the Russians in other words after the war despite the fact that the Russians were allies despite the fact that Kaja Kallas I just learned that last year. [laughter] Do those of you know that said, “Hey, I just learned that the Russians were involved in World War II and actually they were on our side.” [laughter] No, she said that. She said a lot of other stupid things.

So, anyhow, it was really strange that we turned on the Russian, but it was all this visceral anti-communism for God’s sake. Godless anti-communism and there were a lot of crazy things done in those days and you know it was Albert Einstein who said it’s one of my favorite quotes in the future we will be embarrassed by what anti-communism has done to us in terms of turning our lives around. So yeah, Gehlen was head of our section of the using his contacts in the Wehrmacht to keep track of Russians and there were things in Ukraine Gladio and other things like that. So it was a innate fear of Russia. Why? Because they knew Russia would come back and they were communists after all and we don’t give communists any leeway here. So, it was not very reasonable or logical, but the decision was we’re going to cooperate with anybody, including Nazis, if they were against Russia or if they had interesting information on Russia. Sorry to go on that long.

Audience member: Do you see any connection between the two wars that are going on, it seems to me that while Russia has had its hands tied in Ukraine, the United States and Israel have been very busy in the Middle East doing things that they may not have taken on if Russia had been, especially with regard to Syria and that if Russia hadn’t been bogged down in Ukraine. Do you think there’s and I think there was something in the Epstein files about Epstein had written an email to somebody saying that Putin’s opinion was that Zelensky was run by Netanyahu. I just wondered if you see any connection between the two wars. I [laughter]

Craig Murray: I’ll go first. I mean yes definitely I think there’s a attempt to o open the United Front if you like which stretches across Europe and I think that’s undoubtedly true and we see increasing Ukraine Israeli military cooperation going off of drone technology and that kind of thing. I’m I actually just heard my Iranian visa’s been approved and I’m going to Iran next week. Which is the only way I could think of to escape the bloody Christmas day. [laughter] But [laughter] it seems to me very likely that Trump and Netanyahu, who are both in political binds at home, are going to attack Iran. But that seems to me very probable, which is why I want to get there to try to why the hell do I want to go? I want to get try to document, you know, what’s happening and see what’s happening. But the if you look at

Syria for example there you’ve got now a US government-backed regime which had been supplied by the an extraordinary thing they were designated as a terrorist organization and were supplied by the British and the Americans for been to the base in Lebanon the British base in Lebanon from which they were supplied from in the Bekaa Valley. You they were supplied by the British and the Americans for years and years while they were designated as a terrorist organization. They are now put in place. You really can’t divide

These conflicts it in a sense it is part of a grand strategy and you have to put in Venezuela and Cuba into that strategy as well. And a lot of it is about control of oil. I mean it’s another large question but the Americans are perfectly happy for the Strait of Hormuz to be closed. That actually increases American earnings from oil and gas exports particularly to Europe. The United States got very little oil from the Strait of Hormuz anyway. So it doesn’t really affect the [laughter] affect the American economy. And when you put that together with the, you know, the gold grab in Venezuela that

But it’s a fascinating thing. I mean, it’s a very basic question, but you look at what they do to places like Cuba and places like Venezuela if they believe what they say and that capitalism is a naturally superior system and they wouldn’t have to constantly use military force to destroy socialism. But they do every time there is a socialist economy or alternative economic model. You wouldn’t call Iranian socialist, but it’s not on the Western capitalist economic model. They cannot stand the existence of alternative economic models anywhere.

Ray McGovern: I would just add that I agree with what Craig just said. With respect to Iran, there is a big difference and is this is for Netanyahu. I mean, hello. That’s pretty much just like the attack on Iraq was for the Israelis. We have all the evidence. You know, early on I used to say, well, it was three factors. Oil, Israel, and what’s it? Oil, Israel, and logistics. Oil this acronym. Okay. I get got criticized for doing an acronym that had one other word. Oil is well you know I thought it was equal then but it was more than 50% Israel we never got the military bases that we coveted under the legit l of the logistics and we’d get much of the oil either so it was pure and simple to get rid of Saddam Hussein who the Israelis were a threat to us so it’s the same syndrome and that’s what makes in my view the Iran thing different from the Ukraine thing. But I agree

With the business about what Brzezinski said. You know, look, we have to kind of broaden this thing out and take Ukraine and the rest of all otherwise we won’t be in control of Eurasia and of course we’re America. We have to be in control of Eurasia. Those are the kinds of people who are educated who are now called the Soviet the Russian experts and the Chinese experts. So they have this frame of mind even you know even in the little small coterie of advisers to Trump they have an impact and it’s very [unclear] a couple of months ago John Ratcliffe flew to Moscow I’m sorry a couple of months ago John Ratcliffe CIA director flew to Moscow he didn’t get an audience with Putin

He had to meet with his equivalent The narrative was he went to tell them that they’re losing the war. Yeah. [laughter] Can’t be true. Is this? Yeah. Well, I you know, having been a CIA alumnus, [laughter] it’s just crazy. Yeah. That was the New York Times, you know, whether our policy makers really believe that Putin is losing the war. Certainly the major media propagate that fallacy. It’s bollocks if you understand what the English call bollocks, you know. So the notion that he went there to tell the Russians, look, you’re really losing and you know, we know your economy is faltering and you know, come to reason. I don’t buy that at all. I think he went there to say, well, look, you know, I’m in charge of this thing. I do I give these satellite information to the Ukrainians. So, you know, I have a lot of power. I titulually I am a title follower titular follower of the president, but look I’m going to tell you what the real story is. We’re going to keep supplying Ukraine unless you show more flexibility. And that went over like a lead balloon and Russia didn’t get to meet Putin and he was given short shrift and he was sent home packing. I think was all his initiative or Trump’s initiative came to nothing and it was followed by Mutt and Jeff by the two Jeff Mutt and Jeff. Yeah. What’s their name now?

Kushner and Witkoff and they had different instructions. They said look we want to work this thing out. And then they went to Ukraine and well the story is that I think Trump really would like to work something out. He said so the Russians believe him or at least they say so that the Trump is understanding that we have core interests and so that Ratcliffe thing was a real unexplained kind of thing but I think that’s the way

Moderator: Sorry I think probably we take maybe the last questions together then we’ll wind up and go meet but if we I think it gentleman at the back there.

Ukraine, Venezuela and the Palestine Action case

Audience member: Yeah. I just wanted to ask your opinion on what will happen to the Ukrainian intelligence infrastructure in postwar Ukraine because I think it’s generally accepted that like the CIA and MI6 are kind of in control of them. But like the GRU are have a presence in Mali. They’ve like openly boasted about like arming and trading al-Qaeda and militias. Excuse me. They’ve also had like presence in Sudan and I think there was like a Ukrainian military website that posted about creating a Syrian scenario in Mali. It’s interesting that you mentioned that as well. So I just wanted like whenever this war ends what will happen to that because there was like a Washington Post article where a CIA spoke or anonymous source said like we created a new Mossad. So it’s kind I wonder what your opinion is on that.

Moderator: Should we take a couple more?

Audience member: Firstly, I just wanted to say what a beautiful venue this is and congratulate the people behind it. On that and on that note, [applause] on that note, could I just ask you Craig what the role today is of the whistleblower given the current geopolitical context and secondly to tell us a little bit about the case you’re running in Scotland in relation to the proscription of Palestine Action. Two unrelated questions. Thanks.

Moderator: We’ll take one more, even though that’s two.

Audience member: Can I ask you Craig and you were in Venezuela quite recently and what’s your read of what’s going on there? Like everything I read is people that I kind of respect, they seem to be a split in what they’re saying. Some people are saying Delcy Rodríguez is capitulated. Other people are saying she’s playing the long game. I’m just curious what you think.

Craig Murray: Yeah. Well, I’ll go first then Ray can wrap up everything. Now I’ll start with the last one first. Shame. Venezuela is bloody difficult. I’m finding it very hard to understand what’s happening. But when I was there, I met a lot of very good socialists in the Venezuelan government who I’ve got no doubt were committed socialists. And that includes Delcy Rodríguez, who I met one-on-one. And they I heard evidence by which I’m I mean recordings of the night. I heard evidence that left me no doubt at all, absolutely no doubt that Delcy Rodríguez was not implicated in Maduro being taken and was I heard her, you know, on the phone yelling at the Americans. She wanted proof of life. She wanted the president back. Until the president came back, she wasn’t going to talk to them.

The and I also heard recordings from a week before when foreign ministers of two Middle Eastern countries were calling her up and saying to her that the Americans were going to be coming for Maduro and she was telling them to get lost basically. So I’d got no doubt, but I also spoke to numerous people, including Nicolás Maduro’s son, all of whom confirmed to me that the reason there were no American casualties, was that all the Venezuelan armed forces, including the Cuban bodyguards, have been stood down. Which is why you had this tremendous Cuban bodyguard, but no Americans were killed. No, if there had been a firefight with the Cuban bodyguards, there would be dead Americans, but there are none. The Cuban bodyguards in fact were killed were in their barracks and they were killed by missile strikes in their barracks after they’ve been stood down. They were totally unnecessarily killed by the Americans. So that there’s some things in the narrative you hear about Venezuela is just not true. Those things I you know I satisfied myself absolutely with

Talking to eyewitnesses and listening to evidence. All those things I’ve just said are true. What the Venezuelans then said to me is, well, they have to go along at the moment with what Trump was doing and they’d give a bit of ground and then after the midterms, he’d be a dead duck and then maybe they’d be able to start to claw things back and they were basically riding out Trump. They had to go along with it for a while because they weren’t in a position to they weren’t in a position to fight, which they’re not. They’re just not they’re too close to the United States. A too small a country and they have a very weak military. But it seems but ever since then, I

Mean, it’s just obviously gone far too bloody far for that narrative to still maintain. And you see things like Delcy with Hegseth yesterday and I’m pulling my hair out thinking, what is going on here? Because you know, yes, I understand they’re hostage. Yes, I understand they have a metaphorical gun to their head. But they’re really not signal. They’re not doing any virtue signaling to the rest of the world. They’re not showing they’re not happy of what’s happening. They’re not acting like they’re hostage. So I found it extremely difficult to explain. And on top of that, I’m going to continue to find it extremely difficult to explain because they won’t give me a visa and let me go back. So I don’t know is the answer. I believed them when I was there. I really did believe them. But

It now looks very bad. On deep on the Palestine Action on the Scottish Palestine Action case the Scot Scotland of course Scotland has an independent judicial system but in practice Scotland has deferred to England on things like judicial review for centuries. So judicial review is always heard in the high court of England and Wales and the Scottish courts always go along with whatever the English courts. Fine, they don’t have to. That’s not the constitutional position. They’ve just got so used to kowtowing to the English.

And actually historically there was a difference in the Boris Johnson prorogation of Parliament case where when Parliament was prorogued to get Brexit to where there were parallel judicial reviews in Scotland and England and the Scottish court found the prorogation unlawful. The English court found it lawful and eventually the Supreme Court found it unlawful. But that was a real breakthrough because the Scottish courts actually stood up for themselves and said, “Oh no, we’re separate jurisdiction. They got to come to our own decision and we were trying to do exactly the same thing in the Palestine Action case in England and Scotland. But annoyingly, I mean more than annoyingly, incredibly

Frustratingly, the Scottish courts have reverted to their previous position and have postponed have suspended the Scottish case until after the Supreme Court decision. Now you might think that means that once it comes back the they’ll just go along with whatever the Supreme Court said, but actually not necessarily. The Scottish Judicial Review is going to hear the Scotland specific points which are about the fact that nobody in Scotland was consulted. They consulted the weapons manufacturers. They consulted the bloody Israeli embassy. They didn’t consult one single person in Scotland including the Scottish government including police Scotland who are responsible for enforcing the ban and so the specific and also we’re going to bring forward points about the claim of right and things in Scots law which are additional to the ECHR and which prohibit oppressive government. So on top of

Which the Supreme Court was not allowed to look at the designation of terrorism in the first place. That wasn’t allowed as a point of appeal. That had been agreed by the High Court of the Court of Appeal in England. So the Supreme Court wasn’t allowed to look at it. So there’s not been a ruling from a superior court. The Scottish courts are equal to English courts and we can look again at the designation of terrorism. So we so it’s all going to go back and come

Back. Except that we’ve run out of money. The [laughter] the crowdfunding appeal has been closed down by the state on top and they we’ve been through eight seven or eight I can’t remember procedural hearings that they all the time that they do lawfare the government does lawfare it’s been stalled and again by procedural hearings which they always win and every time we lose the costs of that hearing are awarded against us which is like 20 or 30,000 quid a go. So, at the moment we’re out of money, but once the Supreme Court decision comes back, we will be resurrecting the Scottish appeal. I’m not going to comment on the other questions because a I can’t remember what they are and b I’ve spoken too long and I’ll let the [laughter] take over.

Royal honors, Cuba and the press

Ray McGovern: Pardon this, but I think the triple lock would be a good example for the Scots. To the degree the triple lock as he wrote it. What are the Scottish to think? My god they need encouragement. They need a good example

To follow. Now, my grandmother saw Queen Victoria as she was reviewing the troops going off to the Boer War in 1900. Okay? And she was a seamstress for rich lady. And the rich lady said, “Go stand in this corner.” And she saw Queen Victoria and he came by and the window was open and my grandmother said, “So I said, well, how the hell are you?” But I don’t think she heard me. [laughter]

Now, I heard last night after a couple of Guinness, that this good Scot right here had a more diplomatic reaction to another Queen Elizabeth, I never met Queen Elizabeth, but Craig was in good odor for lots of things he had done for Queen Elizabeth. Could you just recount that little story if you could because everyone should know about it. It’s great.

Craig Murray: Oh, okay. So [laughter] I after the first Iran war, sorry, the first Iraq war where I worked in intelligence. I was offered the OBE which I declined. And then later in my career, I organized two state visits, one to Poland and one to

Ghana. And after the state visit to Poland, I was offered the rank of lieutenant of the Royal Victorian Order. And after visit, which I declined, and after the state visit to Ghana, I was offered to be a commander of the Royal Victorian Order. And I was taken in and I saw the Queen and Philip, just me, the Queen and Philip in the room. And she said, “Okay, you do understand that the Royal Victorian order is not a government award. It’s in my personal gift and I this is a personal offer from me to you and you keep declining and I don’t I would be grateful if you tell me why.” She said, I said, “Well, your majesty, I’m a Republican and a Scottish nationalist.” [laughter] And she looked at me and I think probably in her entire life nobody had ever said anything like that to her. [laughter] She still looked at me and she said and she’s absolutely true. She said, “Oh,” she said, “How nice. [laughter] How nice. [applause]

Ray McGovern: Come on. She never asked you to accept the award again, did she? [laughter] let me just say a word about

Venezuela, who used to supply Cuba with oil, right? Cuba is really hurting. The Russians delivered at least one shipload of oil. Rubio, I think, would like to invade Cuba. I see an analogy here where he might well persuade the president to do something like that. And the analogy is this. After 241 US Marines were blown to bits in their barracks in Lebanon in Beirut. It was an awful experience for the White House. And so they withdrew their troops sensibly, but then they thought, “We have to show our muscles somewhere.” And somebody said, “Oh, there are some people in Grenada.” And somebody said, “Where’s Grenada? That’s in the Caribbean, and they’re threatening our medical students. They take could take them hostage.” And so the 82nd Airborne was sent into Grenada of all places without any the various pretense. And we overthrew the old Grenadian government.

And we showed what we could do with our power, right? So, similarly, if you will, we’re going to take a real hit on this Iranian thing in my view, unless Netanyahu blows the whole place up. Okay? So, we’re going to have to compensate. And I’m sure Rubio is going to say, “Look, let’s do Cuba like nobody else has done. Let’s do it.” And will the Russians stop us? That’s the question. The deal after the Cuban missile crisis was no invasion of Cuba. We take our inter we take our medium-range missiles and nuclear weapons out. That was

The deal. Okay. Does it still exist? I don’t know. It’s sort of written down, I suppose, in all the historical documents. I don’t know. But I don’t know if the Russians, you know, it’s a long way away from Russia. The smart people would say, “Well, the Russians would never do much about it.” I’m not so sure, you know. I’m not so sure. Does Rubio think he’d get away with? I’m sure he thinks he’d get away with it, but I’m not so sure. That’s what I think might eventuate from this Venezuelan thing with no oil for Cuba. God help us. Those Cuban people are suffering really bad. And nobody seems to give a rat’s patootie about them, you know. So, again, it’s the media for that. The other question that I could relate to had to do with whistleblowers.

You know, whistleblowing does work. You know, it can prevent the worst things from happening. And even in retrospect, when David McBride, a lawyer who is deployed with the Australian special forces saw incredible indignities, incredible torture and the willful killing of a of Afghans and of everybody else. He was brought back to Australia and he blew the whistle and as some people know better than I he was in two years in prison because he divulged some secrets right secrets about torturing and stuff like that and so we offered him the Sam Adams award as I mentioned before it was just yesterday that he was awarded that by us and by the Australians. Now, nice thing is that Julian Assange came to the ceremony to support David. Julian doesn’t want to do a lot of things just now, but he is coming out. He’s on

Public media and stuff like that. So I am worried about Cuba and I think it could re could eventuate as I tried to explain with an analogy between Grenada and what happened to them to compensate for our loss of stature so to speak by pulling our Marines out of a no-win situation where we had put them in Lebanon. So, the other thing I just don’t know, I can’t really relate to that because I don’t know much about it and my wife tells me not to talk about stuff I don’t know about. [laughter]

Craig Murray: I just said, but I think that I think the notion that it’s really the Ukrainians who are doing those things. It they have Ukrainian intelligence fund people, but it’s a CIA basically. And I think almost certainly that’s going to continue. It’s a new useful proxy they can use in intelligence situations where they don’t want it to be openly the Americans who are backing particular groups. And I don’t I however the Ukraine war comes to an end and I think it will come to an end with almost precisely the same territorial set but could have been reached four years ago with a huge number of dead people for no gain and no loss. But however the Ukrainian war comes to an end I think that will continue. I think [The U.S. Is] using Ukraine as a proxy internationally both in terms of intelligence and in terms of export and drones and things I think is now with us. I think that’s going to stay.

Ray McGovern: If I could add just one general observation. It occurred to me in preparing to answer questions yesterday and today. People should be surprised at how much the media is controlled by the powers that be. My grandmother called them [unclear].

And while I was actually briefing some of the top people down downtown, Secretary of State, Secretary of Defense and all, a new director came in named William Casey and atypically he was made part of the cabinet, which is really very unusual and should be prohibited because the intelligence officer should not be in a cabinet that is a decisionmaking thing. Intelligence officers need to be in support of give the objective information but once they start advocating policy they lose all respect all credibility. So Casey came in and in the first month well it was early February 1981. Okay I just come back from overseas. So he comes in and the first cabinet meeting, Ronald Reagan raises his people around the table and he says, “Okay, now what I want you to all tell me what your primary objective is with the, you know, with respect to the agencies that and the departments that you are in charge of.” And Casey said, “We will believe that our mission is complete when everything the Americans believe is false.” Now, did he really say that? Yes, he really said that. A good friend of mine was there in the room when he said it. A good friend of mine leaked that to Sarah McClendon who was one of the [unclear] reporters in the Washington Post or actually I forget where she worked and so it was divulged

At the time. Now, why do I make that point? Well, as you know, journalists are paid off or bought off or, you know, to get to be a real journalist is really difficult these days. That’s why I’m so delighted to be in the company of so many here and Shay included. But one little vignette showed to me in a personal way how bad it is. Anderson Cooper. Okay. Anderson Cooper. Pretty boy, heir to the Vanderbilt fortune for God’s sake. Okay. So, I challenge Rumsfeld in a public meeting. And he engages me in four minutes of full debate on Iraq. Right. Some of you may

Have seen that. Okay. [laughter] So, on the way out, I get a call. Mr. McGover. Yeah. Anderson Cooper here. Oh, Anderson. How are you? You’re curing you’re causing quite a stir down here in Atlanta. We I would like to have you on my show tonight, but first I have to ask you a question. I said, “What would that be, Anderson?” Well, here it is. Weren’t you afraid?

And I thought for a second, I said, “Well, now wait a second.” had a good Pretty Boy on CNN heir to the Vanderbilt fortune. You know, no Anderson actually I wasn’t afraid. As a matter of fact, there was a big high. It was really high. And you know, you might want to think of preparing real questions for people and you’ll feel this real high and it will really terrific for you know, and it’s well very well. Oh, I’ll have my people get in touch with your people. No, don’t do that. Anderson. Why not? I don’t have any people. [laughter]

Just call me back. Okay. So, bottom line here, he has me on his show. What’s the first question he asks me? Anybody guess? Weren’t you afraid? Right. [laughter] I mean, he didn’t get it for God’s sake.

Shouldn’t he be embarrassed to ask me, “Wasn’t I afraid?” But that’s exactly what he did. And so you that was just sort of a personal experience of how these guys operate. I don’t know. He didn’t need the money for God’s sake. He needed the ego and the but he wasn’t about to ask Rumsfeld or anybody else any serious question that started with Casey with a big push. Of course before that we had co-opted all kinds of European and other but you know went into full. So if people ask you why we don’t know anything or why our colleagues keep asking us dumb questions, well Casey achieved his first and foremost aim. Everything the American people and a lot of the Europeans believe turned out to be false and then we get things like Ukraine and u and Iran. So I’ll finish with that, unless you have something.

Craig Murray: No, I think I’m ready for my [unclear].

Unidentified speaker: Give them a round of applause.

Subscribe
Notify of

0 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest