WATCH: Ray McGovern Accepts James Joyce Award

November 22, 2026

Former C.I.A. analyst Ray McGovern was presented with the 2026 James Joyce Award at a ceremony in University College Dublin on Wednesday.

This is an important day for our friend Ray McGovern, who has been a steady guide to some of the best ideas and work we’ve shared at ScheerPost. Too often, people who know what’s right stay quiet when speaking up might cost them something. Ray speaks up. He has done it time and again, and we’re proud to call him our friend.

This week, the Literary and Historical Society of University College Dublin presented Ray, a former CIA analyst and presidential briefer, with its 2026 James Joyce Award. We’re marking the occasion by sharing these videos and reflections, including Consortium News’ coverage of the award. Congratulations, Ray. Whenever you have something to share, you have a home here at ScheerPost.

Here’s Ray McGovern, in his own words, accepting the 2026 James Joyce Award from the Literary and Historical Society at University College Dublin. Ray spent years briefing presidents and has spent years since speaking plainly about U.S. foreign policy and holding those in power to account. That willingness to speak up when it would be easier to stay quiet is one reason we’re proud to call him our friend. Watch the award presentation and Ray’s speech below, courtesy of Consortium News.

Watch the award presentation and Ray McGovern’s acceptance speech above, courtesy of Consortium News. A transcript of Ray’s remarks follows below.

Camera: Joe Lauria. Editor: Cathy Vogan. 

Thanks to our friends at Consortium News for bringing us Ray McGovern’s James Joyce Award speech from Dublin. If you value independent journalism that gives voices like Ray’s a platform, please consider supporting Consortium News

You can also make a donation to our PayPal or subscribe to our Patreon.

Please share this story and help us grow our network!

Ray McGovern accepts the 2026 James Joyce Award

Editor’s note: Watch the video above, courtesy of Consortium News. The transcript below includes Ray McGovern’s remarks, the conversation that followed, and the audience Q&A. It was edited from the video’s auto-captions for readability. Brackets flag unclear wording and describe audience reactions.

Introduction

Presenter:

Throughout his 27-year career with the CIA, he chaired the national intelligence estimates and worked directly with President Ronald Reagan’s five most senior national security advisers to prepare the President’s Daily Brief. His analysis of the CIA’s role in instigating the Iraq war made him one of America’s most powerful anti-war voices, and he’s the co-founder of the Veteran Intelligence Professionals for Sanity. In 2006, he returned the Intelligence Commendation Medal in protest of the CIA’s use of torture in interrogation. He is a proud father and a grandfather and as of today, our most recent recipient of the James Joyce Award. Ladies and gentlemen, please welcome Ray McGovern.

[Applause]

Acceptance remarks

Ray McGovern:

[It] is really important to me to spend this time to recognize the kind of support that’s kept me going and it’s just delightful to see that you all came and that we had to turn hundreds away after I’ve just been told.

[Laughter]

But you know, this is really nice. Now, let me say a couple of semi-serious things here. I’m going to speak cor ad cor loquitur. You may know that’s on the coat of arms of John Henry Newman who founded not only the society but the whole university if I understand correctly. So I’m going to speak from the heart. Cor ad cor.

When I entered the Central Intelligence Agency, it was early 1963 and it was a spanking new headquarters and there was marble all over the place at the entrance and in the marble chiseled into it was “You shall know the truth, and the truth shall set you free.”

And echoing in my mind was my grandmother Jane’s admonition: “Raymond, be truthful and honest, and then you won’t give a damn what anyone says about you.” [laughter]

Grandma, if that’s true, this is going to be a good place to work. And you’ll be surprised to hear it was because I was doing analysis on the Soviet Union at the time. I wasn’t involved in any of the operations of overthrowing governments or still worse. And so they kept us hermetically sealed and I was able to operate for the first two-thirds of my career without anyone telling me what to say about the evil Soviets or the good Soviets or any kind of Soviets as long as I could back my analysis with facts. That may come as a shock to the young. That’s what we used to do. You would base [it on] hard fact, and as long as I made it cogent and as long as I didn’t misspell things my stuff would go directly to the president often because it was after all the main enemy the Soviet Union

And then came Bill Casey. Now, Bill Casey was actually a strong Irish Catholic, but he was a creature of the Cold War. And at the first cabinet meeting, and by the way, the intelligence chief has no business being at a cabinet meeting. Some of you will know why. Cabinet meetings make decisions on policy. Intelligence officials support policy by giving them information but do not advocate this or that policy otherwise they lose all credibility as you’ll understand. So here’s Casey at the first cabinet meeting and he’s quoted as saying this.

Intelligence and disinformation

A friend of mine was there. We’ll know our disinformation program is complete when everything the American public believes is false.

Oh, [laughter] now that’s pretty extreme. This came after an invitation by the president himself, Reagan, to tell what main objectives each cabinet officer or agency officer had in mind. Now, the interesting thing is that my friend who was there said, “Look, I’m the source for this quote when it hit the papers. My name is Barbara Honegger.” And it was indeed CIA director William Casey early February 1981 a meeting of the newly elected President Reagan with his cabinet secretaries. It was in the Roosevelt room next to the cabinet room. And Reagan asked what he saw, what each cabinet secretary saw as his goal as director. And the CIA Bill Casey said, “Well, that’s what he said. We’ll know our disinformation program is complete when everything the American public and you could extend that to the European public. What else they believe? what they everything the American public believes is false. Now our job my job the job of Joe Lauria and Consortium News or Patrick Kensington our job is to what Martin Luther King Jr. talked about when he talked about the need to fight injustice and lies and let’s see if I can remember what he said. He said, “yeah, here it is.” Like a boil that can never be cured unless it is opened up with all this plus flowing ugliness to the natural medicines of air and light. So true, injustice and lives can never be cured. they must be held up to the light of human conscience and the voice of that of public opinion before it can be cured. And so that’s what we’re doing here. That’s what we have been doing trying to shine light in dark places and I’m delighted some of the people who helped me do that over the years and some of the ones that cheered me on were so successful in doing that. Now, Archbishop Desmond Tutu, I’m proud to say, extremely proud to say, is a former awardee of this award, the James Joyce Award. Not to even mention James Joyce in whose tradition we meet this evening. But I’d like to quote Tutu when he talked about can you be neutral? Here’s a quote. Now, if you’re neutral in situations of injustice, you have chosen the side of the oppressor.

When he was asked to compare life in apartheid South Africa with conditions in occupied Palestine, Tutu said, “Look, people life in Palestine is far more brutal and repressive than in apartheid, South Africa.” My god, he said that and it didn’t put him in prison. that was then this is now he might end up in dire straits now Kipling is worth noting in terms of the people who are being killed right and left when he encouraged his son to serve then he put these words in his dead son’s mouth “If any question why we died, / Tell them, because our fathers lied.”

Now, I want you to recall one instance where I’m not very proud to point out that I didn’t measure up to my own expectations. what happened was there was a there was a situation in Vietnam

Vietnam and the decision to speak out

That I knew firsthand because a friend of mine, Samuel Adams, actually a descendant of John Adams, [unclear], had found out that there were between 500 and 600,000 Viet Cong communists in the south. But the general, General Westmoreland said, “No, there could be no no more than 299,000.”

299 make you suspicious. Anyhow, Sam Adams fought this battle, my friend Sam Adams. and he didn’t prevail in headquarters because our director of the CIA did not want to get in what he called a pissing match with the US army at war. He said my duty is to protect the agency and that’s no way to protect the agency.

That’s how bad it was. All right. Now what I want to talk about is I used to have lunch with my friend Sam Adams and on the 21st of August 1967 when I knew that Westmoreland was deliberately deemphasizing the numbers of the communist arms I said Sam how could this be generals have an incentive to exaggerate the number of enemy they they face what and Sam said look The person Saigon is not going to break but they can do subtraction and we’ll be killing thousands a week. All right. And so if we say now it’s 400 to 5,000 100,000 well then Morton will not be able to explain that. And I said that’s crazy Sam. And then Sam said to me a cable came in just this morning. a notice. Notice means no dissemination at all except in the director’s office.

So what did it say? Well, it was from U General Abrams, Creighton Abrams, who was Westmoreland’s deputy. And what it said was this: I’ve committed it to memory.

We can’t possibly go with the accurate figures of 500,000 to 600,000 because we have been conveying an appearance of progress in this war and if we release the real figures there is no no explanation we could adjuce to persuade the press in Saigon that we weren’t fooling with the figures. Okay. So this is Creighton Abrams, a great tanker during World War II, right? Patton said he was the best one next to Patton. Okay, but he was not astute politically enough to keep this out of the cable traffic. Now, why does that matter to me? Well, I said, Sam, someone released those figures to the New York Times. Now, those of you who are familiar with the New York Times now have to be reminded that way back then in 1967, it was a good possibility the New York Times would print something like that. Sorry if they saw the document and then they said they asked around for a couple of the people, you know, for confirmation, they would print it. So, I said, “Sam, we have to get get hold of that thing.” And he said, “Well, you know, that’s you know, we get thrown out of the agency and then what would the agency do without us? [Laughter]

So instead of trying to weed out a copy of that, it would have taken some doing. I should have tried my best either to get a copy or to go down to the New York Times bureau in Washington and tell them this is August 1967.

All right. Now we know what happened at that was January February the following year 1968. And we know that Westmoreland wanted wanted to get approval for 206,000 more troops to go into Cambodia, Laos to the North Sea, maybe up to the China line. Okay, people might remember what happened that time in in Korea.

Anyhow, I failed failed my own expectations there because I didn’t pursue it as I might have, but I knew Sam wouldn’t because he always followed the rules very closely.

No. let me just say a couple more words here. you bounce back from things like that. and you try not to be disheartened by what happens to fellow journalists. you know that [name unclear] from Switzerland, you know that Glenn Diesen from Norway. Yeah. And who’s it? Hussein. Hussein. Yeah. Chay Bowes. Is he in the Is he in the house? J I invited him. but he couldn’t come. He’s [unclear] at the moment.

Ah okay. So you know when this happens one has to keep his chin up and say well we have to deal with this. We have to deal this way by exposing untruth and injustice like like Martin Luther King Jr. advised us to.

Now, one of the things that happens to me and it may be because I’m so Irish. All of my four grandfathers and mothers came from Ireland. But I get angry. I get really angry, you know. And I was so angry at a lot of this that I remembered by chance something I learned in college if you can believe it. And it was Thomas Aquinas. We had learned a lot about him back in the day, this Jesuit schools. And he railed about the absence of a word for the virtue of anger. Virtue of anger. He was doing he was pretty good on virtue. Not so good on women, whom he said if memory serves were misbegotten males conceived when the moon was not quite right. So you have to be be careful that you know Aquinas was not really good on lots of things but it’s good on virtue. So he said look there’s no how can I write on virtue if there’s no Latin word for it. So look back to John Chrysostom 4th century and Chrysostom said he or she who is not angry when there is due cause for anger sins because anger speech anger looks to the good of justice and if you could live amid injustice with anger [unclear], that’s a sin okay now like to emllish these things as though he had a special input but He railed against what he called unreasoned patience. He said you know unreasoned patience when there is cause for anger sews the seeds of vice nourishes negligence and includes and persuades even good people to do bad things. Wow. So strengthened by that and educated by my good friend father Daniel Berrigan it gave me hope and courage which of course is what Augustine said was necessary hope had two daughters anger and what courage so last thing I’ll say here is that Dan Berrigan Father Berrigan who some of you know a big campaigner against the war in Vietnam. he ended up in a post office which was the only which is the only government building in this little town of Catonsville outside of Baltimore and he he described in his diary in his autobiography while he went through he said you know I kept saying myself was this was this worth doing? I mean, they’re going to call me a communist. They’re going to call me socialist. They’re going to call me all kinds of things. They’ll [unclear] out of the Jesuits. They’ll [unclear]. Was this worth doing? And I came to the realization, says Dan Berrigan, that the good is worth doing because it’s good. results. Results are not unimportant, but they are secondary to the goodness of the act. All right? So, plow ahead, work for equality for blacks in Mississippi, and 70 years later, it will happen. But don’t expect immediate results.

Now I saw Dan Berrigan for the last time in 2013 right after Ed Snowden had released all that damaging information showing that they’re spy in on all of us and they collect all the information on can you believe it. I couldn’t believe it. I asked my NSA colleague Bill I said how can they collect it all? He says, “Look, trust me, Ray. I built some of these systems. They collect now they don’t read it all, but they collect it all.

They can use it whatever they decide to do that.” So, I asked Dan Berrigan and I said, “Look, now I’m going to see I’m going to see Ed Snowden in Moscow in two weeks. Do you have any word for him?” And he was alert and he was up on the news and he looked at me and he made a raspy voice and he said, Yeah. Tell him he did the right thing.

[Laughter]

I said, “Okay.” Now, Dan Ellsberg, another friend of mine who has just passed, he spent a lot of time with you in jail, Father Dan. and I was talking to him just two weeks ago and telling him I could see you. So, do you have any word for for Daniel Ellsberg? [Unclear.] Yeah. Tell him he did the right thing, too.

[Laughter]

Okay, that sounds real simple, isn’t it? Okay. I mean, that’s all we have to do. Got to do the right thing. And sometimes it’s real hard, sometimes it easier. But if we do the right thing and we don’t expect immediate results, well, then I think we’re okay. One thing I’d just say is that with respect to Shannon airport, I was on that delegation where Tarak Kauff and Ken Mayers were arrested for being on the target being out there in the field and trying to prevent American planes from going to places like Afghanistan or Iraq and now the Persian Gulf. my wife swore me not to get arrested that trip and I had some speaking engagements. So they didn’t even tell me what they were going to do. But I’m very proud to be and that in that in that company again solidarity and I would point out I’m proudest still that when the judge ruled that they had to pay a very substantial fine before they got their passports back. Some of you probably know what happened. the people that came to the trial went out to their ATMs and they raised the cash in 1 hour and 50 minutes and they were free. So that’s my idea of Irish solidarity.

There were two people on that delegation who came through Shannon airport armed armed full battle dress with their rifles. So don’t tell me that they’re just passing through and going to the PX or whatever they call the duty-free dutyree place there. All right. So their names are [names unclear].

Okay. So that’s what’s happening and we have the dispute about the triple lock. And maybe maybe I’ll just say a word about well there’s an Irish song and I’ll finish real quick. There’s an Irish song called “Grace.” “Grace, just hold me in your arms and let this moment linger.” Do you know it? Yes. Let’s go. All right. [Singing. Words unclear.] They’ll take me out upon the yard and my thoughts will be with you. And I’ll write some words upon the wall so everyone will know. The triple lock is in place. NATO, we won’t go. Come on, man.

[Applause]

Thank you so much. Thank you.

Conversation with Ray McGovern

Moderator:

Ray, welcome to Dublin. Thank you so much.

Ray McGovern:

Well, I’m I’m with friends and with supporters and family from all over the world and I’m feeling [unclear]. I only drink on even days and so today’s the day [laughter] or two. Yeah, it’s another day when I don’t have a drink. [Laughter]

Moderator:

And you’re practically a local around here. I know you have very deep family connections to Ireland. Could you tell us a bit about that?

Ray McGovern:

Well, my grandmother with whom he lived and was married to a letter carrier at the post office. they built a house in the Bronx which was dairy farm country in those days. And that’s the house my father was literally born in and where I grew up for my first 22 years. And gradually I got to know the McGoverns from Cavan and even more closely the [name unclear] from Galway and from [place unclear]. And there are all kinds of folks here that I recognize finally. Have you seen their faces? They look like [name unclear]. Well, they look like McGoverns. there are

Moderator:

And so Ray, your career kind of started out after you completed your education. It actually started out in the in the US military. How how was that experience like for you?

Ray McGovern:

Well, go back 100 years to it’s not 100 years. Go back to 1957 when I got out of high school. Now the Soviet Union was a real threat then. I mean there’s no no pain in saying that and I had decided to major in Russian and I had some teachers of Russian that loved Russia but hated the communists. I had no teachers like Zbigniew Brzezinski and Richard Pipes who were Polish actually and drank Russophobia from their mother’s breasts. [Laughter] And so I learned Russian history and Russian arts. One of my language teachers was a Russian ballerina. And the more I learned about Russian history and how they had taken it on the chin from the from the Genghis Khan people and then the Lithuanians and you know Estonians and the Hanseatic League and then you have Napoleon and Hitler and you have 27 million I’ll say that again. 27 million Soviet citizens killed in World War II.

But it’s hard not to have a little bit of compassion for what they’ve been through and to try to put yourself in their place. How do they look at the expansion of NATO? Should you disregard their expressions of concern? I don’t think so. That’s why we’re tell you I think I brought one of these things here. I did. I was visiting [names unclear] in Berlin and I was walking by a shop and they had this button and the button it says what’s that name understand right so somebody who tries to understand Putin saying oh wow Wow, [unclear]. Even the Germans are trying to understand. Putin, may I have five of those? And Taylor or children said, “No, no, no. Don’t do that. This means you’re in Putin’s pocket. This is a pejorative. You wouldn’t want to wear this anywhere around Germany.” And I said, “Oh, no. Is that how bad it is?” And that’s how bad it was. This was 10 years ago.

And that’s the way that’s how bad it is now. And so one of my objectives is to draw from my well I made it in German in Russian in 1959 for God’s sake. and there have been decades of experience with the Russians. have been there many times and so I think I understand things and that’s why you’re sort of you pay back because you could be silent about all the stuff but you could face it to the criticism and say no no you got it all wrong and you got it all wrong because Bill Casey was successful

[Laughter]

Let’s face it the media has been promoting things that the media and the military-industrial complex want you to believe so that they don’t spend money making arms and they don’t seem to care about what the Russians think and I think that’s a big mistake and so despite the appropriate and all that kind of we try to try to speak truth to power as they like to say

Moderator:

And as well as being a veteran of the military yourself kind of throughout your career you’ve always made a point of speaking out against senseless war and violence Is it disheartening to be an anti-war activist today?

Ray McGovern:

You know, let me just broad that out a bit. My first civil disobedience was in favor of the ordination of women.

My [Applause] my daughter of 8 years old came back one day from Sunday school and she said, “Yeah, it was a terrible day, terrible day in class. I’m not going back [unclear].” I said, “What’s going on?” She said, “Well, we studying sacraments.” And the teacher came in and he said, “Now this one is only for boys. No, no girls can get this one. It’s called holy order.” And so I said, “Well, that doesn’t seem fair to me.” And Matilda said this evening, we had a row for the whole 60 minutes as to why we should talk about something that’s not available to girls. And I said to myself, wow. [Laughter]

And so some of some of these people know the story. I ended up on the front page of the Washington Report magazine after 5 years of standing standing in place in the middle of the congregation not saying anything not just pointing out that with an indignity and injustice like this in the midst of our worship it’s not true worship and I caught a lot of grief for that but I was proud against solidarities we started something called the working groups on sexism of holy Trinity Church in Georgetown, Washington. It was wonderful. Anyhow, that led me on this road to say, “No, McGomery, you don’t have to you don’t have to kowtow to every authority. You’re not in the army anymore.” And so that led me into when when I saw that my colleagues, my former colleagues I had retired had let themselves be persuaded to use false information to justify in quotes a war of aggression against Iraq which was no threat to us. And I remembered from my history studies, a war of aggression. Yeah. Nuremberg called that the supreme international crime. Different from other war crimes only in so far as it contains the accumulated evil of the whole. Okay? Think torture, think other iniquities that came together with that war. So when I saw my colleagues letting themselves be corrupted into doing and saying what Dick Cheney did, then I said, “Well, okay, let’s bend let’s get some solidarity here.” And there were five of us initially. Long story short, we founded the veteran intelligence professionals for sanity. I should explain the sanity. There wasn’t much sanity going on in Washington at the time. But we’re also doing sanity checks. Email had just just about arrived, but we weren’t really adept at it, but we did use it for a sanity check. In other words, if you’re writing at the CIA, and you’re saying, well, I think we ought to I think we ought to cashier and we ought to fire the vice president, vice president Cheney, which we did. Well, you want to check that out with the people in the next cubicle. Do you think do you think we ought to say this? Well, we could except for checking sanity checks with using email and so that was part of the sanity. But we wrote an article on the afternoon of Colin Powell’s speech and we said look Mr. President you’re being fed a line here if you don’t realize it. Cheney is the fly in the ointment. And we followed up by saying let me see if I could remember. We said look Mr. President, we strongly urge you to widen the circle of your advisers beyond those clearly intent on a war that are not necessary and from which the unintended consequences are likely to be catastrophic.

And of course, they were not so much for the US soldiers killed, but for the Iraqis. And why did we do it? Well, it was very clear to me after a couple of years that it was the same as Iran. Why did we do it when Iraq was no threat to us for Israel? Israel was afraid of Saddam Hussein and they said, you know, we’d like to really replace them and Dick Cheney and Bush said, well, we’ll give it a try and it would be very short.

So, so in other words, when I saw that my friends, my former friends couldn’t couldn’t measure up to standing firm and saying, “No, that’s a lie.” And it was explicit. I just say one more thing that the Senate Intelligence Committee, I’m sorry, Senate Intelligence Committee wrote various appreciations of the intelligence leading up to the Iraq war. Right. And at the end in 2008, their chairman Jay Rockefeller, who just died recently, issued a statement and he said, “The intelligence used to justify the war in Iraq was unsubstantiated, contradictive, or even non-existent.” Period. End quote.

Non-existent. What does that mean? They made it up, folks. They made it up and they’re making it up now on Iran. And you don’t make any friends in Washington by pointing this out. It happens to be the truth. And I think what Martin Luther King others have said what we need to do is have sort of sort of one one place where people could go and consortium news is one of those that people can get the real the real story gradually. I think Israel’s is not having the kind of grip on US politics as it did before we went into these terrible wars at their behalf. But we’ll have to see. The election is a is a good indication, the recent election where it looks like the young people especially are seeing through our bondage to Israel and see that we don’t really do this anymore.

Moderator:

Yeah, I think that the recent election in the US is something that’s kind of been a source of a lot of excitement for people here in Ireland as well because I think with things going on in the world at the moment, sometimes it can be really difficult to have hope. how do you think individuals and especially young people can kind of do good in a world that kind of seems so overwhelming today?

Ray McGovern:

Yeah. Yeah. Well, the first thing as I tried to say before is be angry appropriately angry angry according to acquaintance to practice the virtue of anger and then the next one would be to have the courage to do something about it. Now I have I have more more optimism now than for a long time just by virtue of what happened in the election. We just heard that that black candidate won the senator post in Mississippi. My god. Mississippi. Now, if you go back to my days in college, there were very very courageous like courageous people who went down there, Freedom Riders they call them. they were one I knew they were killed down there in Mississippi and they were fighting for voters rights. Well, again, you know, this these results don’t come right away. 70 years is a long long time to wait, but they do come. And I think that youth need to say, well, you know, it really looks pretty dreary now. You know, let me It was it was John Henry Newman who composed the poem “Lead, Kindly Light”. Does anyone know that “Lead, Kindly Light”? Well, the first the first stanza talks about the situation he faced.

[Recites “Lead, Kindly Light.” The auto-captions are unclear in parts of the recitation.]

Faith, family, and activism

Mhm. John Henry Norman lost a lot of friends. [Unclear.] as as Catholics in the Bronx, but I did memorize it in preparation. Thanks for the opportunity. [Laughter]

Moderator:

It’s actually nice that you mentioned your faith, right? Because it leads me very nicely onto our next question. so I know that you are a man of faith and you’ve grew up with religion and so how does that influence your the path you took throughout your life and kind of your activism?

Ray McGovern:

That’s a wonderful question. I mentioned Dan Berrigan and the people who spoke about spoke against the injustices of Vietnam. I was trained in a traditional way. The theology we learned in the 60s or the 50s really was not was not really quite what it was now. liberation theology. I studied a gentleman’s master’s degree at Georgetown University. Everything but the dissertation. All right? And it was taught by many of the Jesuits going back from Central America. Okay? and they knew what what what was up. They knew what was going on. And one of those Jesuits taught me this. He says, “This is my theology.” Now, get this. This is this is the love of mine as well.

It all depends on who you think God is and how God feels when little people are pushed around. Wow.

Now, we have the opposite. Now in our structures, political structures, little people are pushing around and the 1% even the 1% apparently are for infringing on the triple lock. My god, I couldn’t I couldn’t believe that. It’s happening [unclear]. not only that but did I hear correctly that the Taoiseach has said well it’s all right to imprison Chay Bowes is that correct my god you know he’s a journal I’m a journalist Patrick is a journalist Joe Joe is a journalist journalist here And I think well I know that Craig Murray also a journalist as well as an ambassador and as long as as as also the director of the University of Dundee for a while and having spent how many months in a Scottish prison? Four. Four months in a Scottish prison. For what? What did you do? A contempt of court. Contemptive court. In other words, he wrote things up that he heard in court and it was well anyway they fixed that.

And so a lot of my friends have spent more time in jail than I’ve just been do over lights there [laughter] weekends. They looked at but it’s an instructive experience because you’re you’re not you’re not treated very nicely and you’re you wonder how the ice people treat treat people within these days. But I’m not talking too much again. Please not leave me.

Moderator:

We’re fine. Don’t worry. Ray, we’re really lucky to be joined here by so many people that are very near and dear to you. But there’s one person who unfortunately couldn’t be here with us tonight. Probably the most important person in your life is Rita. Could you tell us a little bit about Rita and I suppose the impact that she’s had on your life and the support that she’s provided you?

Ray McGovern:

My god, what a blessing. I never thought she could be preersued. took five years. I think I mentioned before not here. We sang a song. we have an opera singer here. Brigita Bo, please tand based

[Laughter]

On our plane this morning. [Applause] and she led us in song and we co-recorded one because my wife was asleep when we were trying to do it. So I’m sure that we would be happy. Anyhow, we met during a summer in 1956 and u after 5 years I was able to persuade her and so in 1961 and my brother Larry up there can attest to this. He was the ultra boy I think. Yeah. And so it’s been wonderful and unfortunately she had a stroke about six years ago. So she’s [unclear]. but she has trouble getting around and often gets vertigo which is a real problem. So my eldest daughter Kathleen came in from California to be with her during these days. And that’s a nice support from the rest of the family. One of my sons I mentioned Joseph set up my website 20 years ago and watch this now five years ago he made it incredibly easy to search on. Okay. So, so it’s not very well it’s it’s organized by chronology, but if you want to search something in raymcgovern.com, it’s easy as pie and it took a week for him to make that happen. And now my new webin Kelly, would you stand up there so people can Kelly Lane lives nearby me in North Carolina and she she gets everything on my various platforms. That’s the right word. Is that right? [Unclear.] Katie, over to you.

Moderator:

Well, Ry, I love the saying that behind every great man is an even greater woman. And we really would have loved for Rita to be able to join us here this evening in Dublin, but instead we got her a little present that you can bring back home for. It’s a little [gift description unclear].

Ray McGovern:

Thank you so much.

Moderator:

So you can bring a little bit of Ireland back home.

Ray McGovern:

I will. Now she is the love of my life and I well for a while she was my operations center after left the CIA and I have lots of operations center officers now some of them here that feed me information that will make sure I don’t miss things. But Rita we have five children and 10 grandchildren. Claire is one of our grandchildren. She lives in London and I think I may have introduced her before. But thank you so much for this. Rita will be very happy.

Audience Q&A

Moderator:

I think I’ve been spoiled with time talking to you. I think I’ve asked enough questions, but I’d love to open up the audience if anyone has any questions.

Ray McGovern:

No, please. [Laughter] or something.

Audience member:

Willing to kick things off. What you were saying about the American public everything they believe be true is false. outgoing congressman Thomas Massie gave an interview on Breaking Points in the past week where he said a fake ad was run where now Thomas Massie is 55 and he said this fake ad said that implied that he was in a what’s called a throuple with Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez who’s 37 and Omar who’s 44 10 years his junior and he was saying on breaking points that like look this is so outlandish I didn’t bother with a defamation claim he didn’t show it. He Thomas Massie he said that like the ad was so preposterous he didn’t expect anyone to believe it. He didn’t launch any defamation claim or anything like that until a woman who attended his rally like who was healthy enough to get to one of his rallies and said well in spite of your adultery I’ll still vote for you and said that ad is fake and she goes oh well I’ll best tell my neighbors.

[Laughter]

So h and on the point of health, I would like to congratulate you being older than both Trump and Biden and obviously being cognitively far more robust. [Laughter]

Ray McGovern:

Well, I must say a word because that is Rita’s doing six vegetables a day.

[Laughter]

Audience member:

My god, I remember that. But my broader point is that during the painfully unproductive count lockdowns in 20 2021, I heard this term called fifth generation warfare. I don’t know if you’re familiar with that, but it seems to be an example is like I think it was a Walter Cronkite quote regarding the Vietnam War. It entered the homes of American living rooms. So that if you could go past the front line, past the contact zone to the population and say it’s not worth fighting, that is fifth gener apparently that’s fifth generation warfare. I’m wondering if in your career you ever studied that it’s like well instead of actually I suppose mind games would be what it is except on a societal scale and if in your decades of study of the Soviet Union did you ever come across that or did any of your colleagues talk to you about that?

Ray McGovern:

You know the answer is really no I am of the realistic school of international relations the head of which is John Mearsheimer who I hope you know about and it just you know we follow the facts and try to put them together and sometimes we come up with a kind of a theory like that but it never really entered very much into our deliberations after all I was a glorified journalist But not so glorified actually [laughter] glorified only in the sense that I had access to information from secret sources and satellites and all that kind of thing. But but now I’m just a plain journalist. But you’d probably be interested to know this. But I quoted Bill Casey early February 1981 at the first cabinet meeting. And something else he said that was really important and again came from the same source. She was there and he said you know when I when I came into the agency I found out that 80% of the information that the analysts of the Soviet Union rely on comes from public sources newspapers and various sources and books and things like that. Now, how can they possibly make could I mean for him was all spies, right? You ran spies during World War II. If you didn’t have a spying going on, you could. So, that was how naive he was at that time. And the reason I mentioned it now is now it’s about 90%. Okay. And it comes immediately. I get into TASS I get what what Putin has said in his last thing and it means something. and you follow this stuff and you figure out what’s propaganda, what’s not propaganda. And so it’s a it’s called media analysis, a subdivision of political science, but it works. At least it works really well on Russia. I have to say that I did the President’s Daily Briefer in Moscow. Can you imagine? He says, “So, what does Trump mean by this?” [laughter] Beats the hell out of me. Yeah.

He’s so unpredictable. And so, so how can they depend on except to, in my view, treat him with gloves. Invite him to trilateral meetings like the one in China today with Xi Jinping and Putin. invite him or or come to his meeting with the G G20 in Miami in mid December. Just keep them busy and give him the time like so. Oh, I have a half Okay. Now, I was saying for once that if if it looked like Trump was going to go to China for this big meeting that it was unlikely that he was going to renew the attack on Iran. that’s one of the few times I was right on such things as that. But but I was right and I think that it’s unlikely with she and Putin coming to Miami for the G20 in mid December that well I may be wrong on this but my guess is that this will be enough to persuade persuade Trump to say well do I really want to start another war that I probably can’t win might run out of ammunition and we’ll lose all those bases and I know so many things against restarting the war. But he did it twice, right? I don’t know what I do now. Anyhow, that I hope I’ve tried to answer your question. I don’t want you.

Moderator:

No, I’m fine. I’m used to shouting at everyone, right? [Laughter] yourself.

Audience member:

Hi, you mentioned that you studied Russian in college. Would you speak microphone? You mentioned that you studied Russian in college. I was wondering how many languages do you speak in total? And is Irish do you have a few words of Irish at all?

Ray McGovern:

I don’t want to brag. No.

[Laughter]

And I haven’t met any ancient Greeks or people who speak Latin. but I do Russian, French, German, Spanish act actively. So yeah, but it, you know, it’s just a matter of what you like and I and a willingness to make a make fun of a fool of yourself by by sounding crazy, but I love Russian. It’s except for French. It’s the most beautiful language. I know I don’t know many languages, but I know those ones, you know. So, yeah, and you know, people don’t realize this, but, the Russians didn’t have a written language until the 9th century a D. Now, think about the Egyptians. Think about the Chinese, the Persians. And what happened? Well, there were two priests from Macedonia who went up there and loved them and heard their their epic like Homeric poems that they had all memorized and could recite but they had no way to write down. One was [title unclear] almost like the Odyssey. Anyhow, so they manufactured the language. This is not an exaggeration. They were Greeks, right? So they use the Greek letters for the Greek sound. Then Latin had Latin. Then they had Hebrew and they put the Hebrew and then there ones like J and stuff that they just manufactured a figure for whatever you call it. And so then in the 10th century Prince Vladimir of Kyiv said okay now let’s become Christians now that we write down our literature. I said everybody into the enter the on Sunday we’re going to become Christians. and suddenly became Christians long before the split with Constantinople or whatever it was. So, that’s that’s where they’re coming from. And just to sort of carry that one step further, it wasn’t a century more before the Mongols, the Scandin folks came in from the east and occupied Russia for the next two cent 240 years. So, so as as Europe was coming out of the dark ages, right, into the Renaissance, the Russians are just finished just finished get rid of the Mongol hordes. And then they’re facing the Swedes and the Hanseatic League and others from that part of the world. and Peter the Great beats them away and finally they get back together and they have a what century or two before Hitler comes before Napoleon comes and Hitler. Well, you know, when I had a chance to speak at in Moscow, I had a Oliver Stone is a friend of mine and he asked me to come along and if you’re traveling with Oliver Stone, you get pretty good treatment in in Russia. And I guess what I was going to say is that there was one poignant moment where I didn’t get to see Putin as Oliver did, but I did see next level down a person who did touch with Putin almost every day. he had he had a little dinner of the eight of us and it was very nice to he and his wife and he looked at me and he said, “Now I heard you recite that Russian poem there before the youth group there. why is it that you don’t hate Russia?”

[Laughter]

Well, that’s a really odd question. But their view of people who have been are educated in Russian studies. So that you know most of people now are afraid to hate Russia. I mean that’s I mean you can’t Stephen Cohen whom some of you know is the best political analyst professor very closely and others he tried to endow with a lot of money that he bec that he came by endow a fellowship for people studying Russian in a major university and he wanted to call it the Stephen Cohen Memorial because it was I died of cancer and they wouldn’t take the money. They wouldn’t put Stephen Cohen’s name on the center. They said, “No thanks but no thanks.” That’s how rapidly Russophobic people are. And it goes way back. It started with the British and so forth. So there’s a there’s a history there that I think I know pretty well. I used to teach teach Russian history. So that’s hard to come by these days. So for this very high official to say in a quizzical way we heard we heard the poem which had to do with regarding or being aware of the horrors of war was right before the 80th anniversary of the victory in Europe. he said, “Well, why is it that you don’t hate Russia?” And that hit me like a ton of bricks. And I don’t know, I gave him the answer that I gave you, how I studied, and that they were not Russophobes. They were Russophiles that just didn’t like the communist order. And do I love the Russian people? I do. I’ve been there a long time. I’ve been many, many times there. And do I think Putin is a responsible leader? I thank God for someone so cautious, for someone so perspectious, [laughter] for someone who who did everything he could to avoid having to invade Ukraine.

That’s on the books. You won’t read it in the New York Times or the Washington Post, but I’ve made several lectures you can look up in my website. sometimes the university at which I lecture even allows it to be put on YouTube. Sometimes not. Okay. So anyhow, even the universities are somehow affected by by this academic phobia of Russia. And I just have to say that as I watched and John Mearsheimer is recognized as the head of the realistic school of international relations and he wrote an article in the prestigious journal foreign affairs 11 12 years ago saying the Ukraine crisis is the fault of the west. If the West keeps trying to get Ukraine into NATO, this will inevitably result in the destruction of Ukraine and its people. Period. End quote. Now, that was 12 years ago.

I asked John at a public meeting, John, since that was your position and since you’re well regarded in academ or just speak with you or consult with you and they he looked at me said, “Ray, I’ve been at this for three decades. Never once never once has at the State Department, the CIA or the Pentagon assault my council or my ideas on these things. Well, I’m sure that John Mearsheimer has no delight in the fact that he predicted exactly right because Ukraine has been in large part destroyed. And when I asked John the crucial question, did Putin have any other choice? He said no.

He did everything trying to work out through the Minsk Accords which the French and the Germans fooled him on and now recognize that is François Hollande and the German chancellor at the time the woman named Angela Angela Merkel they invented ah we just did these Minsk Accords to give us time to build up the Ukrainian None forces the NATO standards fully equipped, fully trained and they were ready to go in the Donbas in midFebruary 2022. So John Mearsheimer ended up for saying look if the record shows that Putin did everything he could to prevent having to invade Ukraine but he went ahead and did it because there was no other choice in terms of his responsibilities to protect Russian security. And if you want an analogy the same thing happened to the United States in 1962. I was in the army. What happened in 1962? Cuba. Cuba. The Russians tried to do what we were trying to do in Ukraine. The Russians tried to do with respect to Cuba and the United States. Despite our vigilant intelligence, they put offensive strike missiles in Cuba with nuclear warheads.

Okay. And what did John Kennedy do? Didn’t like it. Okay. He said, “No, you can’t do that.” And did he do something illegal? Well, I sure did. Anybody know what he did? Put in a blockade. They said, “No more Russian troops come come within this reg.” And he enforced it with the navy.

And we came to almost a nuclear exchange. But luckily some of the diplomats available to both sides. Llewellyn Thompson for one on our side and other people on the Russian side thought well we don’t want to destroy the world. let’s figure out some way to and what happened the head of Russ Soviet Union withdrew the missiles. Was that a was that quite a hard thing for do? Yeah, was hard. But he recognized that the core interests of the United States, the defense security of the United States would not allow a major power, in this case Russia, to put offensive strike missiles in short range of Washington, New York, and so forth. 8 minutes, particularly [unclear], and luckily Khrushchev backed down. So there’s a direct analogy there. John Mearsheimer is not the only one to draw that analogy, but I was there. I was in the army. Okay, now just one little footnote here. I arrived at Fort Benning, Georgia, the Army Infantry Training Center. we second lieutenants already commissioned were put through this same training as as the privates. It was pretty rigorous. But there was great disappointment in some of us who were really coming home, right? And we heard about this new weapon called a missile. What was it? Was a It was a rifle that could shoot the Well, I forget what we Anyhow, so we want to practice on this. And we went to the to the surgeon. We said, “Where are they?” And he said, “Well, they they came in from north of here, came through Fort Bennett and took all our weapons with them. They’re all now in Key West, just a few miles off the coast of Cuba. They’re ready to go in. Okay, so u that’s how close we were. We had no weapons with which to train for weeks until I brought them back.

Thank God cooler heads prevailed. And there was a side we have to say there’s a side agreement negotiated by Bobby Kennedy whereby we agreed to withdraw missiles from Turkey but sotto voce not a big thing we would do that in a couple of months and Khrushchev trusted us. Now why do I say Khrushchev trusted us? I say that because this was a moral promise from Bobby Kennedy to Dobrynin, the ambassador. They said, “Yeah, we’ll we’ll take those Jupiter missiles out of Turkey, but let’s not make that part of the deal. The deal is simply we’ll we won’t invade Cuba and you’ll review them at you.” Now, in those days, gentlemen kept promises.

And I just just add this that after the Soviet Union, after the Berlin Wall fell and George HW Bush, whom I know quite well, and stayed in touch even after both of us retired, he sent his secretary of state James Baker to deal with Gorbachev and Shevardnadze, the foreign minister. And this was what James Baker said. But he was a clever lawyer from Texas. He said, “Now, now president wants us to deal here cuz there’s there’s chaos here in in Europe. So this this is what we propose. We’d like to have a reunited Germany.

[Laughter]

I know enough about a reunited Germany at my tender age that I had conceptions and I was wondering what friends were at the time.” Oh yeah, right. and reunited Germany just having suffered 27 million killed by a reunited Germany, right? So they said, “Well, it’s got to be a big quid for this quo.” And James Baker said, “Well, how how about this? Yeah, how about this? We’ll promise not to move NATO one inch to the east of the German border.” cross our hearts, hope to die. We’ll promise that do that if you’ll accept a reunited Germany and Shevardnadze went went back to the Kremlin thought about it came back the next morning and said you promised yes we promised and of course in less than a decade we had twice as many twice as many NATO members as there were one baker made the promise. So when I was in Russia about 10 years ago, I had a chance to meet with a fellow named [name unclear]. He’s a professor Moscow University. I think he’s still alive. And I said, Mr. [name unclear], can you tell me why that agreement was not written down? This is key. if if you ought to remember this, it’s on the final test section if you so he looked at me, he said, “Well, Mr. McGover, well, I’ll give you the two normal reasons. One is that the Germans hadn’t really officially signed off on this and after all of this, you know, had to do with Germany. We knew they’d come along, but they had signed off on it.” And the other thing was the Warsaw Pact still existed you know so juridically speaking how could you get but the real reason they looked me straight in the eye said the real reason Mr. McGovern is we trusted you yuck so the trust that existed back in 1962 and spared us from what looked like the nuclear exchange does not exist anymore. Okay. And that’s that’s a so competitive for that is the caution that I see on the Soviet side on the Russian side I should say and the Chinese and just as a reinforcement to my judgment that they just want to keep Trump busy and in the limelight.

Xi Jinping was in Washington about a month ago, right? And there was a readout they wrote sort of accumulating hey both sides said the same thing but but reading the Chinese one right up top first paragraph was we have decided to strengthen strategic cooperation and so we’re going to have [unclear] in Miami for the G20 in December and Mr. Trump has agreed to go to China for the U APEC meeting that’s going on now. So that’s strategic that’s enhancing strategic

[Laughter]

Is that all there is, you know. Well, yeah, that’s all there is right now. But at least it keeps Trump busy for God’s sake. keep them in the limelight as I said before and hopefully something more good good will come out of this but don’t even something good comes out of it what’s Trump going to say the next day you know so these guys are really dealing with a very very tentative nuclear threat that can’t be dismissed the people around Trump are almost as almost as what crazy as years.

Moderator:

Ray, it’s been a I’m so sorry. We’re kind of just run over time. One quick question because you said I think I think we’ll do ladies first.

[Laughter]

This lady here, sorry.

Audience member:

I was just going to say to Ry, even before John Mearsheimer, even before John Mearsheimer 12 years ago, William Burns, who at the time was the ambassador to Moscow and later became director of the CIA and only left it or Trump sacked him in 20 January 25, he wrote an urgent telegram to Condoleezza Rice at the time stating ing that if the US announced that NATO or that Ukraine would join would will join NATO it could cause a war. How right was Mr. Burns in that telegram at the time?

Ray McGovern:

Yes, thanking that out. That was the 1st of February 2008. Okay. And as Bill Burns was a truth teller in those days when he joined the CIA he sort of converted when he was ambassador to Russia. Yeah. he was called in by Lavrov and Lavrov says do you know what “nyet” means? [laughter] [unclear] Yeah I think so. me now if you keep trying to get Ukraine in NATO there will be probably a civil war in Ukraine and even if there’s not a civil war we will have to decide whether we have to invade Ukraine and we don’t want to do that okay so “Nyet means nyet.” he put that in the title of his telegram how do we have that telegram it was highly classified anybody wiky leak Wikileaks.

DC leaks. You got it. Okay. Julian Assange fished that out for us. So there he was. Now that was the 1st of February 2008. What happened though? Well, the do the NATO summit happened two months later on April, early April. And on April 3rd, there was the declaration, the NATO declaration by all the people there at the behest of Bush and Cheney. And it said, and I quote, the country of Georgia and the country of Ukraine will become members of NATO.

Period. End quote. So what we have, we have the warning on the first, it was Condoleezza Rice and Dick Cheney that did this. Later, Merkel, the chancellor of Germany said, “This is really crazy. We went along. This was very, this is going to be trouble. we went along with it, but you know, whatever we have to do with the we have to do what the United States tells us to do, you know. My god. So, anyhow, so thanks for for mentioning that because there were all kinds of indications that Russians really are afraid of NATO right up on their border. And you know, if

Could I have two more minutes? Two more minutes?

Moderator:

I’m just worried that we’re going to miss our dinner, right?

Ray McGovern:

Oh, well, I’ll be fast here. this is something no one knows.

Well, if you know it, after I’m finished, raise your hand and say, “I knew that all along.” [laughter] On the 21st of December, 2021, so two months before the invasion of Ukraine, the Kremlin called, the White House switchboard and said, “Mr. Putin would like to talk to Mr. Biden like great way answer it’s New Year’s he’s a Delaware no Mr. Would you would really like to talk to Mr. Biden now. Well, to his credit, Biden accepted the call. He was alone in Delaware. All right. So, Putin says, “Look, we’re going to start negotiations on February 9th about how we deal with European problems. I talked to my military people on the 21st of December when I told him that when the US puts offensive strike missiles, hypersonic offensive strike missiles in Ukraine and they will do so, said Putin. They asked me how many minutes then would you have of forewarning Mr. Putin and Mr. The poutine said 5 minutes. That was on the 21st. So it’s 9 days later that Putin calls Biden and he says, “Look, [unclear]. 5 minutes is too little. it would really help the negotiations coming forth if you would agree not to put offensive strike missiles in Ukraine.” And Biden said, and in the readout it says, “President Biden agreed not to put offensive strike missiles in Ukraine.” That he had actually no intention to do that. Wow. 30th of December, 2021. The next day, New Year’s Eve, as never before, [name unclear] and all of all of these people and high leaders in were rejoicing as never before. My god, this satisfies four or five of the eight or nine principles in the draft treaty that we offered to them and they turned down. My god, we’re off to a good start. Well, just to finish up, on the 9th of January, so couple weeks, 10 days later, our negotiators show up in Geneva, Wendy Sherman, heading the State Department delegation, and Ryabkov, the deputy foreign minister, and says, “Wendy, this is so exciting. Let’s get down and work out the details.” She said, “What about what?” He says, “Oh, how about the president’s promise there not to put back missiles in Ukraine?” And when they sh says, “I don’t know anything about that. I don’t have instructions on that.” Lavrov [unclear] Blinken, our secretary of state on the 21st of January. So, right right after this and he says, “Tony Tony Blinken, what’s with this promise that your president made until my president on the 30th of December not to put offensive strike missiles in Ukraine?” And Blinken says, “Forget about it. I wasn’t there with him.” Neither there was Sullivan. He was alone in what’s that place? Delaware. Delaware. Not Baltimore. But Delaware. Yeah, Delaware. So, forget about it. Now, we might, says Tony Blinken, we might be able to we might be able to agree to limit the number of missiles we could in Ukraine, but forget about it.

This is not going to happen. 10 days later, last call between Putin and Biden. the readout says the US decide decided not to talk about offensive strike missiles in Ukraine and they refused to talk about further enlargement of of NATO and so that was the 12th of February on the 24th I guess it was the invasion. So people don’t know. No, let me just ask how many how many of the sides knew about the call from Putin to Biden and the readout from both countries. By the way, you did. Wow, look at that. You know why? I heard you on [name unclear].

[Laughter]

You in the intelligence business, we call that false confirmation. [Laughter] Thank you so much, Katie.

[Applause]

Presentation of the award

Moderator:

Thank you for everyone who joined us. and it’s my pleasure to confer you with the James Joyce Award.

[Applause]

Unidentified speaker:

[Unclear remarks as the ceremony ends.]

Subscribe
Notify of

0 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest