
Austin Sarat ScheerPost
On Monday, Ohio Governor Mike DeWine announced that he is reviewing the cases of people on his state’s death row with a view to using his clemency power before he leaves office. The governor told reporters that he will not follow California Gov. Gavin Newsom’s example by issuing a blanket commutation.
The power to spare life confers on governors an awesome responsibility. They can choose how they want to discharge it.
DeWine wants to make clemency decisions for people sentenced to death on a case-by-case basis. But what he said on Monday suggests he is working with a very limited conception of clemency’s proposes.
As he reviews the cases of the 104 people on Ohio’s death row, I urge him to think more capaciously.
DeWine explained that “lawyers and a jury think a case has been ruled correctly, but that may not be accurate. ‘The governor,’ he said, ‘has additional authority to look at that and maybe see something else that is in there with that individual or with that particular case that maybe the jury legally couldn’t have looked at or the judge legally couldn’t have looked at.'”
DeWine wants to look at “death row cases that may have gone awry in the legal process.”
That is an obviously good thing to do. But clemency is about more than error correction.
As he thinks about what to do about the death penalty before he leaves office, the Ohio Governor, who has already made clear his reservations about capital punishment, should think about the value of being merciful and extending grace not just to those who were mistreated in the legal process.
There are, of course, some who believe that all clemency should be used for is rectifying miscarriages of justice. For example, the philosopher Kathleen Dean Moore writes, “In the American democracy the pardon is not a gift from the sovereign and cannot be exempt, on that ground, from the need for justification.”
In her view, pardons need to be “justified by reasons having to do with what is just.”
This view is not just confined to academic circles. In the last several decades, governors who have granted clemency in capital cases have mostly confined their use of it to rectifying miscarriages of justice.
Reflecting on his service as governor of Texas, George W Bush, an ardent death penalty supporter, laid out his approach to clemency this way: “In every case I would ask: is there any doubt about this individual’s guilt or innocence? And have the courts had ample opportunity to review all the issues in the case?”
During his six years as governor, 152 people were executed in Texas. Bush commuted one death sentence.
That occurred in 1998 when he commuted the sentence of Henry Lucas because of serious doubt about his guilt. As Bush explained, ”I take this action so that all Texans can continue to trust the integrity and fairness of our criminal justice system.”
And in the last two years, another pro-death penalty governor, Alabama’s Kay Ivey, has commuted three death sentences, each for reasons of justice.
In one case, she noted that there was no physical evidence putting the defendant, Rocky Meyers at the scene of the crime, and, as a result, there were real doubts about his guilt. As she put it, “I am not convinced that Mr. Myers is innocent, but I am not so convinced of his guilt as to approve of his execution.”
In the second case, Ivey intervened because one man, Charles Burton, who did not actually fire the fatal shot, was set to be executed after his accomplice, who did the killing, had his sentence reduced to life without parole. “Charles Burton did not shoot the victim, did not direct the triggerman to shoot the victim and had already left the store by the time the shooting occurred,” Ivey said.
Invoking the language of justice, Ivey added, “I cannot proceed in good conscience with the execution of Mr. Burton under such disparate circumstances. I believe it would be unjust for one participant in this crime to be executed while the participant who pulled the trigger was not.”
And on October 21 of this year, Ivey commuted the sentence of Toforest Johnson, saying “I had concerns there was not enough direct evidence to carry out the most serious punishment, death…My decision is not a determination of innocence, but a recognition that the circumstances of this case justify commuting his death sentence to life imprisonment, without possibility of parole.”
I have no doubt that DeWine can find similar instances of injustice that warrant clemency in Ohio.
But right from the start of the Republic clemency has been much more than that about correcting miscarriages of justice.
For example, in 1783, George Washington prayed that God would “ dispose us all, to do Justice, (but also) to love mercy.”
Five year later, Alexander Hamilton urged Americans to embrace mercy as a counterweight to justice which otherwise “would wear a countenance too sanguinary and cruel” Hamilton believed that the contemplation of mercy “would naturally inspire scrupulousness and caution” in those empowered to grant it.
And writing about clemency in the first United States Supreme Court decision on the subject,
then Chief Justice John Marshall called it, “an act of grace…which exempts the individual on
whom it is bestowed from the punishment the law inflicts for a crime he has committed.” Grace, as Marshall understood it is unearned gift offered purely out of goodwill rather than because someone deserved it.
Governor DeWine might also take counsel from one of his predecessors, Governor Mike DiSalle Who described his thinking about clemency in capital cases this way. “I could never get used to the idea that a man would die-even any man guilty of the most incredibly inhuman behavior because I had not exercised the power that was mine as long as I was governor the power to keep him alive.”
“Even when I was convinced of the man’s guilt doubt haunted my unconscious long after the warden had notified me that the prisoner was dead.” He said that when he refused clemency he oh the whole human race an apology and that he could not bear to see the imagined reproach in anyone’s eyes.”
The decisions that await Governor DeWine are as weighty as any person can make. They involve the power to keep people alive.
As he contemplates them, he should recall that ensuring that justice is done is but one virtue. Showing mercy, even when justice has been done, ennobles those who bestow it and sets an example for the citizens he leads and serves.

Austin Sarat
Austin D. Sarat is the William Nelson Cromwell Professor of Jurisprudence and Political Science at Amherst College. He is an internationally renowned scholar whose interdisciplinary work examines law in relation to culture, violence, and the liberal arts. His academic foundation includes a B.A. from Providence College (1969), an M.A. (1970) and Ph.D. (1973) from the University of Wisconsin, and a J.D. from Yale Law School (1988). He has also received honorary degrees, including an LL.D. from Providence College (2008) and an A.M. from Amherst College (1984). Sarat has also been awarded the Jeffrey B. Ferguson Memorial Teaching Prize at Amherst in 2022 and the Ronald Pipkin Service Award as well as many others.
Editor’s Note: At a moment when the once vaunted model of responsible journalism is overwhelmingly the play thing of self-serving billionaires and their corporate scribes, alternatives of integrity are desperately needed, and ScheerPost is one of them. Please support our independent journalism by contributing to our online donation platform, Network for Good, or send a check to our new PO Box. We can’t thank you enough, and promise to keep bringing you this kind of vital news.
You can also make a donation to our PayPal or subscribe to our Patreon.
