
It happened by chance that I came to sit on the porch steps of the house in Brookline, Massachusetts where President John Fitzgerald Kennedy was born and spent the first four years of his life. My wife and I were visiting our granddaughter at college and had just come from breakfast in Brookline Village. I did not know of the house until my daughter mentioned it was nearby, and if we walked back up Beals Street we would pass it. So we did. It was early November, a quiet Sunday morning. The house, a National Historic Site run by the National Park Service, was closed to visitors for the season. The only sound on the old-fashioned tree lined street was a woman at the neighboring house raking leaves with whom we exchanged morning greetings.
To my surprise, the wood framed house with its porch was very similar, but grander, to the house I grew up in in the north Bronx, especially the wood and obscured glass front door with its lace curtain, the lower and upper porches, and color of the paint. I have never been one to visit such historical sites, and although I have written a great deal about JFK’s political life and assassination, I have never gone to his death place in Dallas, Texas. I have always preferred sunrises to sunsets.
Although the CIA killed JFK for his radical turn toward peacemaking, they could never kill his spirit, which lives on in the hearts of people all over the world and which struck me deeply in the quietest of ways on this tranquil morning. My feeling was not political but familial. T.S. Eliot’s words came to me: “. . . but set down / This set down / This: were we led all that way for / Birth or Death?”
On the side of the house there are two glass framed placards. In one titled “A Nice Place to Raise a Family,” John and his older brother Joe – two toddlers – are pictured. What struck me forcefully was John’s face under his wide brimmed hat – unmistakable. A miniature President Kennedy at two years old. Two little boys who would later die for their country, Joe as a naval pilot in WW II and his little brother John at the hands of his own government. Here John was born and here their courage was born, and not by chance. From whence comes courage? I don’t know, but I know it in action. The psychologist’s Rollo May’s words seem apposite to me: “Courage is not a virtue of value among other personal values like love or fidelity. It is the foundation that underlies and gives reality to all other virtues and personal values.”
The house was purchased in 1914 by their father Joseph Kennedy for him and new bride Rose. They lived there with their first four children until 1920, when the house became too small for their growing family. They then moved to a bigger, more opulent house in the neighborhood where three more children were born, including Robert. Joe’s wealth allowed for such a move.
Sitting in the morning silence, I thought of my family, also Irish-Catholic, of eight children plus parents and grandparents who had to double up In our house to make do. My mind drifted with the falling leaves. There was social class, of course, but something deeper still to contemplate. It came slowly.
I remembered the bullet hole in our front door that came from the outside but none of us knew how or when. My sisters and I would often finger it as if a touch might reveal some menacing truth. But it always remained a dark mystery.
Tolstoy’s famous opening line to Anna Karenina came to mind: “All happy families are alike; each unhappy family is unhappy in its own way.”
It sounds profound but like many profundities may be shallow. It is, at least, open to multiple interpretations, which may have been Tolstoy’s intention. Surely this wonderful book is more about Levin and Kitty’s relationship and marriage than it is about Anna, Vronsky, and her suicide. Thus it ends with the birth of Kitty and Levin’s son and Levin’s secret – after he has felt in his soul the reality of the good that is the same for everyone everywhere – which he doesn’t verbalize to Kitty, for when he is about to, she started to speak:
Listen, Kostya, do me a favor, she said. Go to the corner room and see how theyve arranged everything for Sergei Ivanovich. I’m embarrassed to. Did they put in the new washstand?
Levin (Kostya) then changes his mind:
No, I won’t tell her, he thought, as she walked on ahead of him. It’s a secret that’s necessary and important for me alone and inexpressible in words.
This new feeling hasn’t changed me, hasn’t made me happy or suddenly enlightened, as I dreamed – just like the feeling for my son. Nor was there any surprise. And faith or not faith – I don’t know what it is – but this feeling has entered into me just as imperceptibly through suffering and has firmly lodged itself in my soul.
I’ll get angry in the same way with the coachman Ivan, argue in the same way, speak my mind inappropriately, there will be the same wall between my soul’s holy of holies and other people, even my wife, I’ll accuse her in the same way of my own fear and then regret it, I’ll fail in the same way to understand with my reason why I pray, and yet I will pray – but my life now, my whole life, regardless of all that may happen to me, every minute of it is not only not meaningless, as it was before, but has the unquestionable meaning of the good which is in my power to put into it.
So Tolstoy, the master of subtlety, ends where he began – with the question of happiness, that will-o’-the-wisp, and the meaning of life. Like time, everyone knows what happiness is and yet doesn’t. Like time, everyone knows it is real but evanescent, like bubbles on a stream. Not permanent. Not to be sought. Not measurable. A mystery.
Of happiness and despair we have no measure despite our addiction to measuring everything.
Could Joseph and Rose Kennedy ever have imagined that this house of their dreams and the four children raised there would bring them enduring happiness?
“The pursuit of happiness” is so American – officially declared an unalienable right long ago – and it often especially drives the dreams of immigrants and their children. The menacing etymological sense of that word “pursuit” – a chase with hostile intent – seems lost on many. To pursue the sun is to be followed by our shadows, and our shadows often hide what we are fleeing, what is haunting us. Despite the peaceful feeling of this morning on porch steps on a sleeping street, I felt haunted. I imagined it was 1919 and inside the house Joe and Rose were wondering what and why they really wanted out of life for themselves and their four little children. But the house was as silent as a sleeping graveyard.
Joseph Kennedy was surely very ambitious in the business sense and for his children, especially the boys. While he became very wealthy, the pinnacle of his dream of success was for his son to attain to the presidency of the country. But as fate decreed it, the first two sons, Joe and John, had first to face the demonic nature of WW II, which they did courageously. Both were war heroes, but Joe died. The father’s dream of triumph – happiness? – passed from Joe to John, only to once again be thwarted by this son’s death, to be followed by Robert’s.
Tolstoy, another wealthy patriarch who had 13 children with his wife Sophia, eight of whom survived childhood, was obsessed with happiness, death, and the meaning of life. They too had a beautiful house on a large estate. Tolstoy’s beloved brother, ten-year-old Nikolai, had once told the five-year-old Leo there was a green stick with the secret to happiness buried by a ravine on the edge of the forest, a stick upon which were written the secret words that would bring love, peace, and happiness to everyone, and would do away with death, for their mother had died three years earlier and their father would die four years later.
Tolstoy never found it.
As a young writer and scholar preoccupied with death and the meaning of life, newly married and seeking happiness, I had a conversation with Tolstoy’s youngest daughter, Alexandra, who accompanied him on his flight from home and was with him when he died. She was his favorite daughter. I have no memory of our conversation, which seems very odd to me, but it must have concerned this matter of happiness and her father’s quest for meaning. Being in her mid-eighties at the time, perhaps she told me nothing of significance. In my memory, I link our conversation with one I had about the same time with an elderly Dorothy Day of Catholic Worker fame; all I remember is talking to two very stern old women who seemed to have no sense of humor, which frightened me. I have always associated happiness with humor, that without jokes and laughter life would be unbearable.
It was then that I remembered this: I took a walk in the woods and a man met me there, as if he knew I was coming, a man with a long white beard and piercing eyes and we nodded and then he continued beside me and asked me what I was looking for, which startled me, and I was speechless and he said he’s been through here many times, especially by the ravine, and Leo told me he never could find the green stick of happiness his brother once told him was buried there but he was not giving up, he never would do that since he loved his brother who would never lie, he knew the stick existed and that’s why he himself was buried there, and he told me to continue seeking because the stick was real, so we walked on as another man approached us who said his name was Albert, and I said Camus, and he said yes, let’s walk together guys, for these woods are dark and deep I know, but look up at the sky, the clouds have parted and the sparkling sky is speaking to us, right Leo, who said yes, I remember when Andrei in my book War and Peace lay wounded on the battlefield and looked at the sky, I wrote that he realized then that that lofty sky was infinite and that happiness was possible, that especially in the midst of battle you have to look up and realize that, that there are deeper reasons for things and petty concerns shield the spirit of truth and that even in the midst of death and war you can glimpse that reality, and it sounded good, I had heard their spiels before, or had read them to be accurate, they were great writers but this was my life and I couldn’t live in their books, but I wasn’t reading, I was walking, or was I dreaming, and then we came to the end of the path leading out of the woods and the sky opened out from the vast tree cover and they were gone and I was all alone again as usual, dispirited and heading back home on the road by the lake when I looked up at the sparkling blue sky and light that radiated off the snowy frozen lake and rose back to the sky in columns of undulating glory and felt the sun that had warmed the day and heard birds in the trees and was overwhelmed with a rush of happiness I can’t describe but it was not a dream and I walked in joy for a few minutes, knowing I had found the stick and that in the depth of winter, as Albert said, I had finally learned that there was in me an invincible summer, but that it came and went like running water, like flowing air, but it was enough for now.
It was no joke, but it made me happily burst out laughing. The porch door to 83 Beals Steet opened behind me and a woman said, “Please be quiet, the babies are sleeping.”
As I got up to go, I remembered the feel of the bullet hole in the front door of my childhood home.


Edward J. Curtin Jr.
Edward Curtin is a sociologist, researcher, poet, essayist, journalist, novelist…writer — beyond a cage of categories. His new book is “At the Lost and Found: Personal & Political Dispatches of Resistance and Hope,” (Clarity Press),
Editor’s Note: At a moment when the once vaunted model of responsible journalism is overwhelmingly the play thing of self-serving billionaires and their corporate scribes, alternatives of integrity are desperately needed, and ScheerPost is one of them. Please support our independent journalism by contributing to our online donation platform, Network for Good, or send a check to our new PO Box. We can’t thank you enough, and promise to keep bringing you this kind of vital news.
You can also make a donation to our PayPal or subscribe to our Patreon.
